per person

Press the down arrow key to interact with the calendar and select a date. Press the question mark key to get the keyboard shortcuts for changing dates.

Caterer does not deliver to that address

About this Package

Assortment of fresh Baked bagels; Sweet butter, plain cream cheese, veggie cream cheese, lox spread cream cheese and fruit preserves.

What's Included?

Assortment of fresh Baked bagels; Sweet butter, plain cream cheese, veggie cream cheese, lox spread cream cheese and fruit preserves

More Details

Breakfast > Bagels & Pastries
Set up style
Drop Off — Delivery person will drop off your order (bagged or boxed) but will not unwrap or arrange anything
Presentation style
Platter — Portions are preassembled by the caterer and served on large platters

$4 per person plus delivery & service

$40 minimum order

4 hours order notice required

Available Add Ons

Bottled water ($2 each)

Soda ($2 each)

Coffee box & the works for 10x ($25 each)

Tea bags & hot water for 10x ($25 each)

Juice ($3 each)

Fruit platter (serves 8-10) ($50 each)

Cookie & brownie platter (serves 8-10) ($50 each)

Hummus & pita platter (serves 8 - 10) ($40 each)

Reviews of N.Y. Bagel Breakfast

Overall Customer Satisfaction

5 star
4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star

Top Customer Reviews

5 stars

March, 2018 · 10 people

Show 1 more review by this customer


5 stars

January, 2018 · 11 people

This order was placed as a thank you breakfast for our sales & marketing team. Although I wasn't present personally, I've received stellar feedback from the team. They said everything was fabulous.

July, 2016 · 40 people

Aside from forgetting some bagel condiments, which they were able to run over to us before our meeting, we enjoyed the presentation and quantity of bagels and would order again.

November, 2016 · 18 people

As I'm gluten-free I could not eat anything - however my co-workers were very happy with the assortment and freshness of bagels and cream-cheeses. Will order again from them for sure!

August, 2016 · 16 people



I've ordered from Benvenuto once before and the order was accurate but they arrived 30 minutes early.
This time around, they arrived 20 minutes early and the order was wrong, I had to send it back and the correct order arrived 45 minutes later, LATE. They did not compensate for any of the inconvenience, HIGHLY DISAPPOINTED.

May, 2015 · 14 people

About the Caterer

Square 1dpgro6ystojqcrtcqrp 2busers 5332 p1riv9esqq2kveqx1ggg dsc 0862


On-Time Delivery
Response Rate
Response Time
3 hours
251 reviews
23 packages

I deliver to...

  • Lower Manhattan
    $10 Delivery Fee
  • Williamsburg
    Does not deliver
  • DUMBO & Downtown Brooklyn
    Does not deliver
  • Queens
    Does not deliver
  • Outer Brooklyn
    Does not deliver
  • Mid-Brooklyn
    Does not deliver
  • Upper Manhattan
    Does not deliver
  • Uptown
    Does not deliver
  • Midtown
    Does not deliver

My business hours are...

Sunday 6:00 am - 11:00 pm
Monday 6:00 am - 11:00 pm
Tuesday 6:00 am - 11:00 pm
Wednesday 6:00 am - 11:00 pm
Thursday 6:00 am - 11:00 pm
Friday 6:00 am - 11:00 pm
Saturday 6:00 am - 11:00 pm
Customize & Order
star Right Triangle checkmark Heart CaterCow Cow Heart New Popular Trending Spring Things Last Minute Fireworks