Miss Lily's logo - one of the top restaurants for catering in New York City

Miss Lily's

109 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009, USA

4.93 (95 reviews)

100% Recent Order Success Rate

0 issues in the last 18 orders

Miss Lily's Catering Reviews

Mollie S.

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Kim V.

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Adrienne G.

Feb, 2025

4 stars

Alex Y.

Jan, 2025

5 stars

Sequoia

Jan, 2025

Always super delicious, GREAT Portions and we love how the sides(rice and roti or plantain) are always sufficient amount and placed on the side!

Sinia R.

Jan, 2025

5 stars

Zainab B.

Jan, 2025

5 stars

Dewey C.

Dec, 2024

5 stars

Stephanie M.

Nov, 2024

BEST Caribbean food I ever ordered! Team went nuts for it.

Zainab B.

Nov, 2024

5 stars

Sinia R.

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Tiffany H.

Aug, 2024

Delicious!

Adrienne G.

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Lana V.

Aug, 2024

Big hit in the office! The portions were generous and everyone loved it. Highly recommend the jerk chicken. Will be ordering this again soon.

Reorg F.

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Zainab B.

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Jeffrey C.

Jul, 2024

5 stars

Zainab B.

Jul, 2024

5 stars

Zainab B.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Katie B.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

enza P.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Sinia R.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Sharif B.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Zainab B.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Stephanie J.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Zainab B.

May, 2024

5 stars

Kings C.

May, 2024

5 stars

enza P.

May, 2024

5 stars

Alimot-Shadiat A.

May, 2024

5 stars

Victoria

Apr, 2024

Great!

Kings C.

Mar, 2024

5 stars

Rosalee R.

Mar, 2024

5 stars

Sam K.

Feb, 2024

5 stars

Alondra A.

Feb, 2024

4 stars

Sinia R.

Dec, 2023

Please tape up the containers Oxtail is shipped in or oxtail gravy to prevent severe spilling please.

Stephanie J.

Nov, 2023

The food was absolutely phenomenal!!!! The office could NOT stop raving about how good their food is! As a Jamaican myself, I was quite impressed by this cuisine as the taste is truly authentic and super flavorful. 10/10 will order again.

enza P.

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Zainab B.

Jul, 2023

4 stars

Amelia L.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

enza P.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Amelia L.

May, 2023

AMAZING! We love Miss Lily's and it was a big hit for our Founders of Color event

enza p.

Feb, 2023

5 stars

Amelia L.

Jan, 2023

5 stars

kay B.

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Roxana M.

Sep, 2022

Delicious food and everyone loved it

Amelia L.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

enza p.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

enza p.

Aug, 2022

5 stars

SueAnn D.

May, 2022

5 stars

enza p.

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Kings C.

Oct, 2021

5 stars

enza p.

Mar, 2020

5 stars

Larissa V.

Oct, 2019

5 stars

enza p.

Oct, 2019

5 stars

Azzerraya L.

Aug, 2019

5 stars

enza p.

Jun, 2019

5 stars

Michele

May, 2019

5 stars

Arcade E.

May, 2019

5 stars

enza p.

Apr, 2019

The team loved!! Everything was amazing!!!

Rasha A.

Apr, 2019

DELICIOUS, great portions--early arrival; will definitely be a staple in our office!

Amanda K.

Apr, 2019

5 stars

Larissa V.

Apr, 2019

5 stars

Arcade E.

Apr, 2019

5 stars

Rustun N.

Mar, 2019

the food was great and the guests were all super happy

Nathan S.

Mar, 2019

5 stars

MELISSA J.

Feb, 2019

Delicious! Will definitely order again.

Arcade E.

Jan, 2019

5 stars

Azzerraya L.

Nov, 2018

5 stars

Vyera P.

Oct, 2018

4 stars

Arcade E.

Sep, 2018

fantastic!! everybody loved the food!! Great job.

Danielle G.

Sep, 2018

Amazing food! Ordered for a company happy hour. Ordering was super easy. Someone checked in to make sure everything was on track the next day. And food arrived promptly 20 min before delivery time. Will definitely order again!

Nickey-Ann B.

Aug, 2018

team loved it!

Arcade E.

Jul, 2018

5 stars

amneris c.

Jul, 2018

5 stars

Pilot F.

May, 2018

3 stars

Azzerraya L.

May, 2018

Office favorite! Great portions.

Lauren F.

Apr, 2018

Clients raved about the food. They were even coming back for seconds!

Sean

Mar, 2018

Amazing stuff! Obviously the proteins and plantains were great, but I was also pleasantly surprised how aromatic and tasty the rice & peas were, as well as how fresh the salad was (yay for mango in it!)

Azzerraya L.

Mar, 2018

5 stars

Eden G.

Mar, 2018

Lunch by Miss Lily's was a huge hit at the office. We received more than enough food, enough for leftovers. It arrived on time and the food was fresh and delicious! Great lunch, will definitely order again!

Marie G.

Feb, 2018

5 stars

justin l.

Sep, 2017

Awesome!

Lyft

Jul, 2017

Individual style Miss Lily's was great!

Lyft

Feb, 2017

Great! It was super good!

Lyft

Jun, 2016

The food was FANTASTIC! Everyone was pleased.

Hannah B.

Oct, 2015

AMAZING FOOD. One of the top food orders for the office we have had so far. Great portion sizings.

Meghan H.

Feb, 2015

Absolutely awesome! Our team loved the food and may be one of our new favorites. So much delicious food!

Mike G.

Aug, 2014

We ordered for 150 people and it was deeeeelish! Thanks!

Get To Know CaterCow

Empower Your Team with Group Ordering

Select a menu and then send a link to your team, letting everyone pick their perfect meal. No need to send a million emails or keep track in a clunky spreadsheet. Plus, there is no confusion when the order arrives - each meal is labeled with each individual's name!

Learn More
Let Us Concierge Your Meal Program

Sure, CaterCow makes it easy to plan your meals and order yourself but that can be draining! Go on autopilot and one of our account managers can craft the perfect meal plan to meet your team's recurring catering needs while you focus on your regular day-to-day. No contracts! No hassle!

Learn More
Earn Rewards on Every Order

Share your CaterCow experiences through reviews and earn CaterCoins. Use them to treat your team to a discounted future order or to snag an Amazon gift card. (Because you deserve it!)

Learn More

Miss Lily's Catering Delivery Information

Brooklyn
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
DUMBO & Downtown Brooklyn12% + $20$300
Williamsburg12% + $20$300
East Williamsburg and Bushwick12% + $20$300
Outer Brooklyn West12% + $20$300
Prospect Park East12% + $20$300
Prospect Park West12% + $20$300
Clinton Hill and Bed Stuy12% + $20$300
Outer Brooklyn East12% + $20$300
Manhattan
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
East Village12% $250
West & Greenwich Village12% $250
SoHo And Tribeca12% $250
Lower East Side12% $250
FiDi12% $250
Midtown East12% $250
Midtown West12% $250
Upper East Side12% $300
Upper West Side12% $300
Harlem12% $300
Washington Heights & The Bronx12% $300
Queens
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
Long Island City and Greenpoint12% + $20$300
Astoria & Roosevelt Island12% + $20$300
Mid-Queens12% + $20$300
Outer Queens12% + $20$300
New Jersey
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
Jersey City & Hoboken12% + $30$300
Bayonne12% + $30$300
Newark12% + $30$300
Linden to New Brunswick12% + $80$300
North Jersey Suburbs12% + $80$300
Staten Island
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
Staten Island12% + $30$300
Westchester County
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
Yonkers, Eastchester, and Larchmont12% + $30$300
Rye, White Plains, and Tarrytown12% + $80$300
Metro North Connecticut12% + $80$300
Long Island
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
Long Island12% + $80$300

Miss Lily's Catering Hours

Tuesday11:30am-5:00pm
Wednesday11:30am-5:00pm
Thursday11:30am-5:00pm
Friday11:30am-5:00pm