"
Atlantic Bagels Catering logo - one of the top restaurants for catering in New York City

Atlantic Bagels Catering

200 Clinton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

4.81 (477 reviews)

100% Recent Order Success Rate

0 issues in the last 19 orders

Atlantic Bagels Catering Catering Reviews

Gail B.

Mar, 2025

5 stars

Melinda

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Zainab B.

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Gail B.

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Michelle R.

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Gail B.

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Nicole V.

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Evelyn F.

Feb, 2025

Bagels were a huge hit for breakfast!

Alexandra V.

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Zainab B.

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Zainab B.

Jan, 2025

5 stars

Gail B.

Jan, 2025

5 stars

Gail B.

Jan, 2025

5 stars

Danni W.

Jan, 2025

4 stars

Stephanie M.

Jan, 2025

Great!

N'Dea R.

Dec, 2024

5 stars

Zainab B.

Dec, 2024

5 stars

Adrienne G.

Nov, 2024

3 stars

Emma M.

Nov, 2024

5 stars

Gail B.

Nov, 2024

5 stars

Dana

Nov, 2024

Great first order with CaterCow! Though, I do wish we received notifications for when the order is out for delivery. The process was seamless and smooth nonetheless.

Tina P.

Nov, 2024

I like their sandwiches more than the wraps, but still good and hearty and tasty! Seamless delivery!

Becca H.

Oct, 2024

The team enjoyed this meal.

Stephanie M.

Oct, 2024

Great food and delivery as always

Gail B.

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Tina P.

Oct, 2024

The sandwiches are excellent!

Zainab B.

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Tina P.

Oct, 2024

Excellent sandwiches!

Mervin M.

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Sami H.

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Gail B.

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Gail B.

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Tina P.

Oct, 2024

Excellent service, always on time, fresh foods.

Tina P.

Oct, 2024

Bagels are fresh and yummy. Danishes were really good. Fruit was fresh. Generous portions.

Leadership P.

Sep, 2024

5 stars

Nathalie T.

Sep, 2024

5 stars

Crystal B.

Sep, 2024

BYO Salad or Quinoa Bowl Bar was a major success! We have some staff members with dietary restrictions so this option offers a little something for everyone.

Gail B.

Sep, 2024

5 stars

Teresa S.

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Gail B.

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Gail B.

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Amelia L.

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Joana F.

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Tina P.

Aug, 2024

Great wraps, very generous portions - enough to split one. Will definitely order from again!

Crystal B.

Jul, 2024

The wraps were so fulling everyone was stuffed! Thank you! :)

Luis V.

Jul, 2024

5 stars

Gail B.

Jul, 2024

5 stars

Pamela R.

Jul, 2024

4 stars

Gail B.

Jul, 2024

5 stars

Claudia C.

Jul, 2024

On-time and the pastries were fresh.

Ashley D.

Jul, 2024

the wraps were a hit!! We ordered a small potato salad and would order that in a larger size next time.

Gail B.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Paige A.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Breakthrough N.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Gail B.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Courtney S.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Catherine H.

Jun, 2024

Great customer service!

Gail B.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Jeffrey C.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Paige A.

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Paige A.

May, 2024

5 stars

Gail B.

May, 2024

5 stars

Ashley D.

May, 2024

The paninis arrived hot and were delicious!

Paul

May, 2024

5 stars

Alimot-Shadiat A.

May, 2024

2 stars

Dewey C.

May, 2024

5 stars

Paige A.

May, 2024

5 stars

Nancy M.

May, 2024

5 stars

Rosemarie R.

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Paige A.

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Tina P.

Apr, 2024

Great setup - food was loved by all!

Tina P.

Apr, 2024

These bagel breakfast sandwiches were great!

Ana P.

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Gail B.

Apr, 2024

These sandwiches have become a staple with our Board Members. Members say they are delicious, and Delivery is always on time; food is still warm no need for warmers which is a plus.

Paul

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Paige A.

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Teresa S.

Mar, 2024

5 stars

Paige A.

Mar, 2024

5 stars

Fatima O.

Mar, 2024

5 stars

Sarah B.

Mar, 2024

4 stars

Amelia L.

Mar, 2024

5 stars

Kerrick D.

Feb, 2024

Service, food, and punctuality were perfect. Thankful for the last minute accommodation.

Paige A.

Feb, 2024

5 stars

Eddillice G.

Feb, 2024

5 stars

Jonathan A.

Feb, 2024

3 stars

Gail B.

Jan, 2024

5 stars

Paige A.

Jan, 2024

5 stars

Heather F.

Dec, 2023

5 stars

Gail B.

Dec, 2023

5 stars

Paige A.

Dec, 2023

5 stars

Tiarra B.

Nov, 2023

5 stars

enza P.

Nov, 2023

5 stars

Richie A.

Oct, 2023

4 stars

Brooklyn Prospect H.

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Gail B.

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Delta R.

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Tiarra B.

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Tiarra B.

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Gail B.

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Shaneese L.

Oct, 2023

3 stars

Tiarra B.

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Nick C.

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Info L.

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Shaneese L.

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Info L.

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Wesley C.

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Tiarra B.

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Allison T.

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Fatima O.

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Jericha R.

Aug, 2023

3 stars

Tiarra B.

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Tiarra B.

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Tiarra B.

Jul, 2023

5 stars

Verified Customer

Jul, 2023

I was exceptionally pleased with all aspects of my recent CaterCow experience. Customer service is exceptional - friendly, helpful and you can actually speak with a live person! It's great to have a reliable company to work with in NYC.

Kseniya R.

Jul, 2023

5 stars

Allison T.

Jul, 2023

5 stars

Arlene S.

Jul, 2023

5 stars

Hannah S.

Jul, 2023

5 stars

Goran M.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Kimberly T.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Goran M.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Goran M.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Lea M.

Jun, 2023

4 stars

Allison T.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Sinia R.

Jun, 2023

2 stars

Lea M.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Lea M.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Michael K.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Megin T.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Lea M.

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Daniel V.

May, 2023

5 stars

Gabriella C.

May, 2023

Thanks for the fresh salad bar!!

Eddillice G.

May, 2023

5 stars

Daniel V.

May, 2023

5 stars

Daniel V.

May, 2023

5 stars

Allison T.

May, 2023

5 stars

Goran M.

May, 2023

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

May, 2023

5 stars

Laurie D.

Apr, 2023

Once again, CaterCow came through with flying colors. Although I was disappointed that the caterer we'd used previously was no longer an option, CaterCow worked with me to identify an alternative vendor (Atlantic Catering). I had a few special orders which were clearly identified, and the entire process came off without a hitch. Food was tasty and well-presented.

Amy C.

Apr, 2023

5 stars

Melinda

Apr, 2023

Arrived early and great amount of food. impressed how perfect the avocados where.

Allison T.

Apr, 2023

5 stars

Megin T.

Apr, 2023

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Amelia L.

Mar, 2023

5 stars

LaShawn H.

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Kseniya R.

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Megin T.

Feb, 2023

5 stars

Kseniya R.

Feb, 2023

5 stars

Jericha

Feb, 2023

5 stars

Godwina T.

Feb, 2023

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Roxana M.

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Courtney S.

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

Dec, 2022

Very late but everyone loved their food so if they can get their delivery times in check we’d really like to use them again.

Kevin K.

Dec, 2022

4 stars

Kseniya R.

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Upper C.

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Nick C.

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Patricia C.

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Lisa K.

Nov, 2022

4 stars

Gabrielle D.

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Roxana M.

Nov, 2022

Awesome and delicious. Everyone loved the bagels

Mollie S.

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Ana B.

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Cora P.

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Sarah R.

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Gretchen (.

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Gretchen (.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Danielle H.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Reed T.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Reed T.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Kseniya R.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Amanda B.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Katie S.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Arcesium

Sep, 2022

5 stars

International Elementary Charter School

Sep, 2022

Staff members loved the variety of different paninis. Good amount of food.

anna g.

Sep, 2022

5 stars

International Elementary Charter School

Aug, 2022

5 stars

Gretchen (.

Aug, 2022

5 stars

Hannah S.

Aug, 2022

5 stars

Hannah S.

Aug, 2022

5 stars

Daniela T.

Aug, 2022

1 stars

Louisa B.

Aug, 2022

5 stars

Louisa B.

Jul, 2022

5 stars

Justine P.

Jun, 2022

Delish & easy to eat at our lunch mtg. Delivery was right on time and courteous.

Michelle R.

May, 2022

4 stars

Sabrina T.

Apr, 2022

4 stars

Alex L.

Apr, 2022

Came without the cream cheese assortment. When I asked them to come back, they only brought one, which was nowhere near enough. And definitely not an "assortment"

LaShawn H.

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Melinda

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Lindsay C.

Mar, 2022

Delicious!

Maximus D.

Mar, 2022

Good bagels. Decent amount of cream cheese.

Arcesium

Mar, 2022

Delivery was on time ( even a tiny bit early, which was great!), bagels were fresh and still warm, and the texture was fantastic. My favorite was the bits of real strawberry in the strawberry cream cheese. Everyone loved these- would definitely order again!

Fedna B.

Mar, 2022

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

Mar, 2022

5 stars

Get To Know CaterCow

Empower Your Team with Group Ordering

Select a menu and then send a link to your team, letting everyone pick their perfect meal. No need to send a million emails or keep track in a clunky spreadsheet. Plus, there is no confusion when the order arrives - each meal is labeled with each individual's name!

Learn More
Let Us Concierge Your Meal Program

Sure, CaterCow makes it easy to plan your meals and order yourself but that can be draining! Go on autopilot and one of our account managers can craft the perfect meal plan to meet your team's recurring catering needs while you focus on your regular day-to-day. No contracts! No hassle!

Learn More
Earn Rewards on Every Order

Share your CaterCow experiences through reviews and earn CaterCoins. Use them to treat your team to a discounted future order or to snag an Amazon gift card. (Because you deserve it!)

Learn More

Atlantic Bagels Catering Catering Delivery Information

Brooklyn
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
DUMBO & Downtown Brooklyn$45$150
Williamsburg$45$150
East Williamsburg and Bushwick$45$150
Outer Brooklyn West12% $350
Prospect Park East12.5% $200
Prospect Park West12.5% $200
Clinton Hill and Bed Stuy12.5% $200
Outer Brooklyn East12.5% $200
Manhattan
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
East Village$45$250
West & Greenwich Village12.5% $250
SoHo And Tribeca$45$250
Lower East Side$45$250
FiDi$45$250
Midtown East$45$250
Midtown West$45$250
Upper East Side$55$250
Upper West Side$55$250
Harlem$60$250
Washington Heights & The Bronx$60$250
Queens
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
Long Island City and Greenpoint$50$250
Astoria & Roosevelt Island$55$250
Mid-Queens$55$250
Outer Queens$60$250

Atlantic Bagels Catering Catering Hours

Monday7:30am-5:00pm
Tuesday7:30am-5:00pm
Wednesday7:30am-5:00pm
Thursday7:30am-5:00pm
Friday7:30am-5:00pm
Saturday8:00am-5:00pm
Sunday8:00am-5:00pm

Atlantic Bagels Catering Catering Packages