A La Carte
If our catering packages don't fit your needs, Utopia Bagels also offers a la carte ordering.
Schmear Sandwiches
Build Your Own Schmear Sandwich
Choice of Bread • Preparation Option • Choice of Schmear • Add Cheese • Add Protein • Add Vegetables • Add Condiments
$4.03
Egg Sandwiches
Build Your Own Egg Sandwich
Choice of Bread • Preparation Option • Choice of Egg Style • Add Cheese • Add Protein • Add Vegetables • Add Potato • Add Cream Cheese • Add Condiments
$7.19
Sandwiches & Toasts
Build Your Own Nova Sandwich
Choice of Bread • Preparation Option • Choice of Nova • Choice of Cream Cheese • Add Cheese • Add Vegetables • Add Condiments
$16.39
Build Your Own Lunch Sandwich
Choice of Bread • Preparation Option • Choice of Protein • Add Cheese • Add Protein • Add Vegetables • Add Condiments • Add Cream Cheese
$10.93
Avocado Toast
Choice of Bagel • Add Protein • Add Vegetables
$10.64
Pastries
Almond Croissant
$5.75
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$4.60
Chocolate Croissant
$5.75
Croissant
$4.89
Blueberry Muffin
$4.60
Blueberry Scone
$5.75
Chocolate Chip Muffin
$4.60
Cinnamon Sugar Bun
$5.75
Corn Muffin
$4.60
Cranberry Orange Muffin
$4.60
Cranberry Pecan Cookie
$4.60
Raisin Bran Muffin
$4.60
Salads
Cranberry Chicken Salad
Spinach, grilled chicken, cranberry, walnut, feta & balsamic vinaigrette
$14.89
Sides
Autumn Butternut Squash Soup
$9.14
Side of Coleslaw
$4.50
Soup Homemade Chicken Noodle
$9.14
Side of Macaroni Salad
$4.50
Mediterranean Lentil Soup
$9.14
Side of Potato Salad
$4.50
Side of Hashbrown
$2.30
Side of Home Fries
$6.90
Side of Bacon 4 pieces
$6.90
Yogurt Parfait
Vanilla yogurt, granola, blueberries & strawberries
$7.99
Snacks
Black & White Cookies
$12.59
Hal's Barbecue Chips
$2.59
Hal's Jalapeno Chips
$2.59
Hal's Original Chips
$2.59
Hal's Salt and Vinegar Chips
$2.59
Rainbow Cookies (One Rainbow Cookies serves ~15)
$16.04
Rugelach (One Rugelach serves ~9)
$16.04
Bagel Platters
2 Dozen Bagel Platter and 2 Cream Cheese (Serves ~24 per dozen)
Choice of Bagels • Choice of Cream Cheese
$85.00
10 Cream Cheese Bagel Platter 10 sandwiches
Assorted cream cheese sandwiches of our most popular options
$75.00
10 Egg Sandwich Platter 10 sandwiches
Assorted sandwiches of our most popular options
$125.00
10 Nova Sandwich Bagel Platter 10 sandwiches
Assorted sandwiches of our most popular options
$200.00
10 Lunch Sandwich Bagel Platter 10 sandwiches
Assorted sandwiches of our most popular options
$150.00
Nova Platter (Serves ~10 per platter)
Comes with lettuce, tomato, red onion and capers
Add Nova
$100.00
Deli Salads by the Pound
Pound of Egg Salad (Serves ~4 per pound)
$18.50
Pound of Tuna Salad (Serves ~4 per pound)
$21.50
Pound of Chicken Salad (Serves ~4 per pound)
$21.50
Pound of Country Chicken Salad (Serves ~4 per pound)
Cranberry-walnut
$22.50
Pound of Chipotle Chicken Salad (Serves ~4 per pound)
$22.50
Pound of White Fish Salad (Serves ~4 per pound)
$27.50
Nova by the Pound
Pound of Nova (Serves ~4 per pound)
$58.00
Pound of Pastrami Nova (Serves ~4 per pound)
$60.00
Pound of Belly Nova (Serves ~4 per pound)
$60.00
Pound of Everything Seed Nova (Serves ~4 per pound)
$60.00
Cream Cheese by the Pound
Pound of Butter (Serves ~8 per pound)
$10.00
Pound of Jelly (Serves ~8 per pound)
$10.00
Pound of Plain Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$13.00
Pound of Scallion Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Vegetable Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Cinnamon Apple Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Jalapeño Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Bacon Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$16.50
Pound of Olive Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Strawberry Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Blueberry Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Oreo Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Birthday Cake Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$15.00
Pound of Nova Spread (Serves ~8 per pound)
$19.50
Low Fat Cream Cheese by the Pound
Pound of Low Fat Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$16.50
Pound of Low Fat Scallion Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$17.50
Pound of Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$17.50
Tofu Spreads by the Pound
Pound of Tofu Cream Cheese (Serves ~8 per pound)
$16.50
Pound of Tofu Vegetable (Serves ~8 per pound)
$17.50
Pound of Tofu Scallion (Serves ~8 per pound)
$17.50
Pound of Tofu Strawberry (Serves ~8 per pound)
$17.50
Pound of Tofu Blueberry (Serves ~8 per pound)
$17.50
Catering Trays
Egg Tray (Serves ~20 per tray)
$50.00
Bacon Tray (Serves ~20 per tray)
$50.00
Sausage Tray (Serves ~20 per tray)
$50.00
Home Fries Tray (Serves ~20 per tray)
$50.00
Fruit Salad Tray (Serves ~20 per tray)
$50.00
Catering Pastries
Box of Joe (Serves ~8 per box)
$30.00
Pastry Platter (Serves ~12 per platter)
$60.00
Mini Cookie Platter (Serves ~30 per platter)
Assorted mini cookies
$60.00
Beverages
Celsius Grape
$5.46
Celsius Kiwi Guava
$4.54
Coca-Cola Can
$2.59
Coca-Cola Diet Can
$2.59
Darigold Chocolate Milk
$4.54
Dr. Brown's Black Cherry
$3.45
Dr. Brown's Cream Soda
$3.45
Hal's Soda Black Cherry Seltzer
$3.74
Hal's Soda Ginger Ale
$3.74
Hal's Soda Lime Seltzer
$3.74
Hal's Soda Original Seltzer
$3.74
Just Tea Green Tea
$4.54
Just Tea Half N Half
$4.54
Just Tea Peach
$4.54
Martinelli's Apple Juice
$5.18
Poppi Orange
$3.74
Poppi Raspberry Rose
$5.46
Sprite Can
$2.59
Tropicana Cranberry
$4.03
Tropicana Lemonade
$4.03
Utopia Bagels Artesian Water 16.9 Oz
$3.45
Fresh Made Juices
Blueberry Lemonade Juice
$11.44
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice
$11.44
Morning Greens Juice
$11.44
Red Refresh Juice
$11.44
Be The First To Review This Restaurant & Earn 2,000 CaterCoins
We are constantly adding new restaurants on CaterCow, so some menus haven't been reviewed yet!
Order now and leave a review and you will receive 2,000 CaterCoins, redeemable for Amazon Gift Cards or a discount off future orders!
Utopia Bagels Locations on CaterCow
New York
Long Island City
New York
Allow Us To Introduce Ourselves
What is CaterCow?
We're an online catering marketplace featuring vetted menus designed to work for groups large and small.
Food with personality.
No more uninspired sandwich boxes. Pick from unique, seasonal options curated by our team.
Easy to use.
We've streamlined the process for ordering food for your group, just the click of a button and your job is done.
Have A Question?
or call us at (855) 269-4056

