Donut Ice Cream Sandwiches - The Ultimate NYC Birthday Treat🍩🍦🎉

There are birthday treats, and then there are Cruffs—Stuffed Ice Cream’s jaw-droppingly indulgent donut ice cream sandwiches that somehow manage to be both Instagram gold and an actual flavor explosion. If you’re in NYC and planning a birthday party that needs to stand out, forget cupcakes. Skip the standard sheet cake. Cruffs are the new king of the birthday table.

What Exactly Is a Cruff?

Imagine this: a warm, fluffy donut, sliced open and stuffed with ultra-premium ice cream, then topped with crunchy, colorful, syrup-drizzled perfection. And the best part? When you order through CaterCow, everyone gets their own pre-portioned kit: one donut, one serving of ice cream, toppings on the side—ready to build your dream sandwich.

This means no melting mess, no sticky scooping situation, just pure DIY delight.

Flavors That Make You Rethink Dessert

Stuffed Ice Cream isn’t shy when it comes to flavor combos. You get to choose up to four Cruff styles from a menu that’s as wild as it is genius. A few we had to try:

Thai Kwon Dough: Thai tea meets Vietnamese coffee, with almonds and condensed milk—a power duo with serious caffeine vibes.

Unicorn Poop: Yes, you read that right. White chocolate lavender + Thai tea + fruity pebbles = sweet, floral, and totally magical.

The Mint Monster: Andes peppermint, cookie monster ice cream, Oreos, and Captain Crunch. It's part toothpaste, part pure nostalgia, in the best possible way.

Cookie Road: Cookie Monster ice cream with chocolate, Oreos, and syrup—it’s a chocoholic’s dream and kid favorite rolled into one.

We’re still thinking about the Unicorn Poop, by the way. Don’t knock it 'til you try it.

Final Verdict: Cruffs Are Birthday Royalty 👑

Forget cookie platters or dry cupcakes. Cruffs are where bold flavor meets birthday fun. They’re extra in the best way possible—wild flavors, interactive builds, and a level of novelty that even New Yorkers stop and snap.

For the price, the presentation, and the sheer joy they bring, Cruffs are officially our pick for NYC’s most unforgettable birthday dessert.

Check them out and order here:
👉 Cruffs Donut Ice Cream Sandwiches by Stuffed Ice Cream

👉 On-Site Ice Cream and Donut Ice Cream Sandwich Bar by Stuffed Ice Cream