CaterCow
Cares

Puddin' Shooters

36 reviews

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery
Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery
New York

Decadent layers of cake or cookies, pudding and whipped cream. A unique twist on the classic trifle! It's delicious, see for yourself what people are talking about.

Package Details

Whats Included?

Your choice of Flavors (up to 4)

Category

Desserts > Specialty

Set up style

Drop Off - Delivery person will drop off your order (bagged or boxed) but will not unwrap or arrange anything

Presentation style

Platter - Portions are preassembled by the caterer and served on large platters

Pricing

$3 per person plus delivery & service, $18 minimum order, 24 hours order notice required

Default choices

The CaterCow experts have pre-selected these choices that we consider to be crowd favorites!

Your choice of Flavors (up to 4)

  • Classic Banana Pudding with Nilla Wafers
    V
  • Chocolate Chip Deliciousness: layers of fresh chocolate chip cookies, butterscotch pudding and whipped cream
    V
  • SLT: strawberry lemon trifle with layers of lemon cake, fresh strawberries and whipped cream
    V
  • Coffee Java X-Press: layers of our mocha loca cake, coffee pudding and coffee whipped cream & chocolate cookie crumble
    V

All choices

If you'd like to customize your order, choose from the following options on the checkout page:

Your choice of Flavors (up to 4)

  • Classic Banana Pudding with Nilla Wafers
    V
  • Chocolate Chip Deliciousness: layers of fresh chocolate chip cookies, butterscotch pudding and whipped cream
    V
  • Chocolate Bomb: layers of chocolate cake, chocolate pudding and chocolate chipped cream
    V
  • SLT: strawberry lemon trifle with layers of lemon cake, fresh strawberries and whipped cream
    V
  • The Nog: layers of pumpkin cake, eggnog pudding, whipped cream and dash of nutmeg
    V
  • Awesome Pudding: layers of chocolate pudding, whipped peanut butter and fresh peanut butter cookies
    V
  • Coffee Java X-Press: layers of our mocha loca cake, coffee pudding and coffee whipped cream & chocolate cookie crumble
    V
  • Sexy Red Velvet Pudding: layers of sexy red velvet cake, vanilla pudding, sweet cream cheese, whipped cream and toasted pecans
    V
  • Mint Chocolate Chip Deliciousness: fresh mint chocolate chip cookies, vanilla pudding and mint whipped cream
    V

Available Add Ons

  • Crazy Cookie Platter (priced per person, 3 cookies per person)

Reviews

Puddin' Shooters
Overall Customer Satisfaction

36 reviews

5 Star (33)
4 Star (1)
3 Star (2)
2 Star (0)
1 Star (0)

Tapad Admin

3 stars

Feb, 2019

Elizabeth Whipple

The pudding cups were perfect for an office treat. They tasted great and were a hit. I've been asked to order these again. Chocolate Chip was the most popular, followed by the Banana. The cups are small enough to have 1-2 per person so order accordingly. Easy recommendation.

Feb, 2018

Stephanie Spiegel

5 stars

Jul, 2018

Watson Program Coordinator

5 stars

Mar, 2019

Becky

5 stars

Nov, 2018

Dina Agalarova

5 stars

May, 2019

Linibelle Minaya

These are amazing! I have been ordering from them for the past months and the puddings never disappoint....and the owner and staff are so attentive and always trying to make you happy!

Mar, 2018

James

These are delicious!

Jan, 2020

michelle r avant

Great shooters! Just enough for a treat!

Apr, 2018

Danielle

Loved it!

Oct, 2018

Monica Gonzalez

on time and everyone enjoyed!

May, 2018

Meghan Turville

They were so good I wish I had a bigger portion. Definitely will order again.

Jun, 2019

Brandon Powell

5 stars

Mar, 2018

Anna Callaway

4 stars

Jul, 2018

Rachel Hassett

3 stars

Jul, 2019

Anonymous

Everyone loved them and kept asking where I got them!

Aug, 2018

Attune (Lena Roufaeal)

Delish!

Aug, 2018

Alexandra

These were DELICIOUS. Everyone in the office is begging me wondering when we can order them again!!

Feb, 2019

Nikolas Skarlatos

5 stars

Oct, 2018

AKQA

5 stars

Dec, 2018

TrialSpark

AMAZING

May, 2019

Katie Kumbar

Delightful presentation, super popular flavors. Great job!

Oct, 2019

Caterer Info

On-Time Delivery Not enough data
Response Rate 100%
Response Time 1 hour

Delivery Areas

Area Delivery Fee
Lower Manhattan $30
Midtown $30
Uptown $35
Upper Manhattan $50
Mid-Brooklyn $40
Outer Brooklyn $50
Queens $75
DUMBO & Downtown Brooklyn $40
Williamsburg $40

Business Hours

Sunday Closed
Monday 9:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday 9:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday 9:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday 9:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday 9:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday 12:00 PM - 4:00 PM

$3/Person

Please enter your delivery details to order this package.

TOTAL price - delivery, tax, and fee included. You will not be charged yet.

Have A Question?

or call us at 1 (855) 269 4056

Also by this Caterer

Loading more packages...