Action Center

0 Pending Items

You don't have any actions that need your attention at the moment.

Sign Up
Important, please read. Due to delivery logistics, Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery will deliver your order within a 2-hour window. The delivery time you choose will be the tail end of the 2-hour window (e.g. if you choose 3:00 pm, your delivery window will be 1:00-3:00 pm). Thank you for understanding!

Superstar Cupcakes

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery

By Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery

  • 365 Grand St, New York, NY 10002

5.0 (19 reviews)

100% Recent Order Success Rate

0 issues in the last 21 orders

Sugar Sweet Sunshine's Superstar cupcakes! It's all in the name :)

Sustainability Measures
✊🏿✊✊🏾✊🏼

Menu: $3.75

Staff Pick

Menu checked for nuts.

Unless an item is explicitly tagged with (N), everything else on this menu is nut free.

Disclaimer: restaurant carries nuts, so there is risk of cross contamination.

Choice of Cupcakes

Up to 5*

  • Sunshine Cupcake V

    Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream

  • Bob Cupcake V N

    Yellow cake with chocolate almond buttercream

  • Ooey Gooey Cupcake V N

    Chocolate cake with chocolate almond buttercream

  • Sexy Red Velvet Cupcake V

    Red velvet cake with "the moose" (swiss buttercream)

  • Sassy Red Velvet Cupcake V N

    Red velvet cake with chocolate almond buttercream

  • Black & White. . . Just Right Cupcake V

    Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream

  • Pistachio Cupcake V N

    Pistachio cake with "the moose" (swiss buttercream)

  • Pumpkin Cupcake V

    Pumpkin cake with cream cheese icing

  • Lemon Yummy Cupcake V

    Lemon cake with lemon buttercream

  • Faux-Coconut Cupcake V

    Coconut cake with satin buttercream

  • Strawberry Cupcake V

    Strawberry cake with cream cheese buttercream

  • Holla Back Girl Cupcake V

    Banana cake with cream cheese icing

  • Oreo Cookie Cupcake V

    Oreo cupcake with satin buttercream

  • Gluten-Free Cupcakes V GF +$1.25 (12 minimum)

    Assorted flavors

  • Vegan Sunshine Cupcake Cupcake VG

    Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream

  • Vegan Black & White Cupcake VG

    Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream

  • Vegan Chocolate Explosion Cupcake VG

    Vegan chocolate cake with vegan chocolate buttercream. So decadent!

  • Vegan French Toast Cupcake VG

    Vanilla cupcake with cinnamon and nutmeg spiced vanilla buttercream

  • Gluten-Free Vegan Cupcakes VG GF +$1.25 (12 minimum)

    Assorted flavors

Choice of Optional Upgrade

Optional (Up to 1)

  • Custom Decoration +$1.00

    Add a short message (1-2 words) to your cupcakes! use the special request box at checkout to let us know what message to add and we will make it happen :)

Full Menu

Looking for more options? Toggle to Full Menu to see all available options.

The Cast of Cakes & Cupcakes

  • Sunshine Cupcake V 1 other size available

    Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream

    $3.75

  • Bob Cupcake V N 1 other size available

    Yellow cake with chocolate almond buttercream

    $3.75

  • Ooey Gooey Cupcake V N 1 other size available

    Chocolate cake with chocolate almond buttercream

    $3.75

  • Sexy Red Velvet Cupcake V 1 other size available

    Red velvet cake with "the moose" (swiss buttercream)

    $3.75

  • Sassy Red Velvet Cupcake V N 1 other size available

    Red velvet cake with chocolate almond buttercream

    $3.75

  • Black & White. . . Just Right Cupcake V 1 other size available

    Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream

    $3.75

  • Pistachio Cupcake V N 1 other size available

    Pistachio cake with "the moose" (swiss buttercream)

    $3.75

  • Pumpkin Cupcake V 1 other size available

    Pumpkin cake with cream cheese icing

    $3.75

  • Lemon Yummy Cupcake V 1 other size available

    Lemon cake with lemon buttercream

    $3.75

  • Faux-Coconut Cupcake V 1 other size available

    Coconut cake with satin buttercream

    $3.75

  • Strawberry Cupcake V 1 other size available

    Strawberry cake with cream cheese buttercream

    $3.75

  • Holla Back Girl Cupcake V 1 other size available

    Banana cake with cream cheese icing

    $3.75

  • Oreo Cookie Cupcake V 1 other size available

    Oreo cupcake with satin buttercream

    $3.75

  • Gluten-Free Cupcakes V GF (12 minimum)

    Assorted flavors

    $5.00

Vegan Cupcakes

100% vegan

  • Vegan Sunshine Cupcake Cupcake VG 1 other size available

    Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream

    $3.75

  • Vegan Black & White Cupcake VG 1 other size available

    Chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream

    $3.75

  • Vegan Chocolate Explosion Cupcake VG 1 other size available

    Vegan chocolate cake with vegan chocolate buttercream. So decadent!

    $3.75

  • Vegan French Toast Cupcake VG 1 other size available

    Vanilla cupcake with cinnamon and nutmeg spiced vanilla buttercream

    $3.75

  • Gluten-Free Vegan Cupcakes VG GF (24 minimum)

    Assorted flavors

    $5.00

Mini Cupcakes

  • Dozen Mini Cupcakes V Serves ~6 per dozen

    Mini cupcakes are made to order. Please order at least 48 hours from the time you would like to have them. Mini cupcakes are served as 1 dozen per cake flavor

    Choice of Cupcake

    $24.90

Cookies! Hot Out of the Oven

  • Chocolate Chip Cookie V 1 other size available

    $0.75

  • Mint Chocolate Chip Cookie V 1 other size available

    $0.75

  • Oatmeal Raisin Cookie V 1 other size available

    $0.75

  • Sugar Cookie V 1 other size available

    $0.75

  • Ginger Cookie V 1 other size available

    $0.75

  • Iced Sugar Cookie V 1 other size available

    $2.25

Vegan Cookies

Vegan cookies require 24 hour advance notice

  • Dozen of Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies VG Serves ~6 per dozen

    $15.00

  • Dozen of Vegan Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies VG Serves ~6 per dozen

    $15.00

  • Dozen of Vegan Iced Sugar Cookies VG Serves ~6 per dozen

    $36.00

Bars

  • Oooh... Brownies V

    Espresso brownie

    $4.50

  • Yum-Yum Bar V N

    Shortbread crust layered with semi-sweet chocolate chips, raspberry and a walnut & chocolate chip topping

    $4.50

  • Chocolate Pepperment Brownies V

    $5.00

  • Gluten-Free Brownies V GF (12 minimum)

    $5.75

The Puddin' Posse

  • 10oz Serving of Banana Puddin' V 2 other sizes available Serves ~2 per serving

    With nilla wafers

    $7.00

  • 10oz Serving of Chocolate Chip Deliciousness V 2 other sizes available Serves ~2 per serving

    Layers of fresh chocolate chip cookies, butterscotch pudding and whipped cream

    $7.00

  • 10oz Serving of Chocolate Bomb V 2 other sizes available Serves ~2 per serving

    Layers of chocolate cake, chocolate pudding and chocolate chipped cream

    $7.00

  • 10oz Serving of The Coffee Java Xpress Puddin' V 2 other sizes available Serves ~2 per serving

    Layers of our mocha loca cake, coffee pudding and coffee whipped cream & chocolate cookie crumble

    $7.00

  • 10oz Serving of Sexy Red Velvet Puddin' V N 2 other sizes available Serves ~2 per serving

    Layers of sexy red velvet cake, vanilla pudding, sweet cream cheese, whipped cream and toasted pecans

    $7.00

  • 10oz Serving of The Nog Puddin' V 2 other sizes available Serves ~2 per serving

    Layers of pumpkin cake, eggnog pudding, whipped cream and dash of nutmeg

    $7.00

  • 10oz Serving of Strawberry Lemon Trifle Puddin' V 2 other sizes available Serves ~2 per serving

    Strawberry lemon trifle with layers of lemon cake, fresh strawberries and whipped cream

    $7.00

Pudding Shots

  • Banana Puddin' Shot V 4 ounces

    With nilla wafers

    $4.75

  • Chocolate Chip Deliciousness Shot V 4 ounces

    Layers of fresh chocolate chip cookies, butterscotch pudding and whipped cream

    $4.75

  • Chocolate Bomb Shot V 4 ounces

    Layers of chocolate cake, chocolate pudding and chocolate chipped cream

    $4.75

  • The Coffee Java Xpress Puddin' Shot V 4 ounces

    Layers of our mocha loca cake, coffee pudding and coffee whipped cream & chocolate cookie crumble

    $4.75

  • Sexy Red Velvet Puddin' Shot V N 4 ounces

    Layers of sexy red velvet cake, vanilla pudding, sweet cream cheese, whipped cream and toasted pecans

    $4.75

  • The Nog Puddin' Shot V 4 ounces

    Layers of pumpkin cake, eggnog pudding, whipped cream and dash of nutmeg

    $4.75

  • Strawberry Lemon Trifle Puddin' Shot V 4 ounces

    Strawberry lemon trifle with layers of lemon cake, fresh strawberries and whipped cream

    $4.75

Not Layer Cakes

  • Slice of Pistachio Bundt Cake V N

    $4.50

  • Pistachio Bundt Cake V N Serves ~12 per cake

    $45.00

  • Slice of Marble Bundt Cake V

    $4.50

  • Marble Bundt Cake V Serves ~12 per cake

    $45.00

  • Slice of Vegan Chocolate Chip Bundt Cake VG

    $5.00

  • Vegan Chocolate Chip Bundt Cake VG Serves ~8 per cake

    $50.00

  • Slice of Lemon Bundt Cake V

    $4.50

  • Lemon Bundt Cake V Serves ~12 per cake

    $45.00

  • Slice of Inescapeable Apple Cake V

    $4.50

  • Inescapable Apple Cake V Serves ~12 per cake

    Classic bundt cake with chunks of apple

    $45.00

  • Slice of "The Real Deal" Coffee Cake V N

    With cinnamon and walnuts

    $4.50

  • "The Real Deal" Coffee Cake V N Serves ~12 per cake

    With cinnamon and walnuts

    $45.00

  • Pineapple Upside-Down Cake V N Serves ~12 per cake

    Contains pecans

    $45.00

  • Slice of I Love New York Cheesecake V

    $6.50

  • I Love New York Cheesecake V Serves ~8 per cheesecake

    $60.00

Layer Cakes

Layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice

  • 4" Double Layer Cake V 6 other sizes available Serves ~4 per cake

    Choice of Icing • Choice of Cake Flavor

    $25.00

  • 7" Triple Layer Cake V 1 other size available Serves ~8 per cake

    Choice of Icing • Choice of Cake Flavor

    $50.00

  • 9" X 12" Quarter Single Layer Cake V 1 other size available Serves ~12 per cake

    Choice of Icing • Choice of Cake Flavor

    $60.00

  • 18" X 24" Full Sheet Cake V Serves ~105 per sheet cake

    Choice of Icing • Choice of Cake Flavor

    $245.00

Pies, Pies, Pies!

  • 4.5" Individual Apple Pie V 1 other size available

    $6.50

  • 4.5" Individual Strawberry Rhubarb Pie V 1 other size available

    $6.50

  • 4.5" Individual Pecan Pie V N 1 other size available

    $6.50

  • 4.5" Individual Pumpkin Pie V 1 other size available

    $6.50

  • 4.5" Individual Blueberry Crispy Crumble Pie V 1 other size available

    $6.50

  • 4.5" Individual Coconut Cream Pie V 1 other size available

    $7.00

  • Slice of Peanut Butter Ice Box Pie V N 1 other size available

    $7.00

Sugar Sweet Specialties

  • 7" Double Layer Strawberry Shortcake V 1 other size available Serves ~8 per shortcake

    $63.00

  • Serving of Tres Leche with Rum V

    $8.00

  • Serving of Flan V GF 1 other size available

    $6.50

Seasonal Offerings

  • Heart-Shaped Brownie V (12 minimum)

    Rich chocolate chip brownie topped with a red heart or kiss-shaped candy

    $5.00

  • Frightful Friends Cupcakes VG (12 minimum)

    Halloween inspired cupcakes

    Choice of Cupcakes Flavor

    $4.50

  • Order of Winter Season Mini Cupcakes VG (12 minimum) 2 mini cupcakes

    Winter inspired mini cupcakes!

    Choice of Cupcake • Choice of Decorations

    $4.25

  • Order of Winter Holiday Cookie V (12 minimum) 2 cookies

    Choice of Decorations

    $4.50

  • Valentine's Day Cookies V (12 minimum)

    Assorted valentine's day themed cookies

    $2.25

  • Vegan Iced Sugar Cookies VG (12 minimum)

    $3.00

  • Valentine's Day Cupcakes VG (12 minimum)

    Choice of Flavor

    $4.50

  • Halloween Sugar Monster Cupcakes VG (12 minimum)

    Choice of Cupcakes Flavor

    $4.50

  • Assorted Treats V (12 minimum)

    Assortment of brownies, chocolate chip, mint chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, sugar, and red velvet cookies

    $4.50

Not What You Were Looking For?

Check out more from this restaurant: Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery Full Menu.

Or search for similar package types in your area:

Desserts Baked Goods Buffet Style

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery Catering Reviews

Loading reviews...

Have A Question?

or call us at (855) 269-4056

We Also Recommend