
All Day Classics Bagel Sandwiches
Whether you prefer classic turkey or a comforting egg salad, there's a bagel sandwich here for everyone. Enjoy the perfect blend of nostalgia and modern taste in every bite!
$14.50 Per Person
0 Pending Items
You don't have any actions that need your attention at the moment.


Egg & Cheese Bagel
Simple, but far from ordinary. Organic eggs, softly folded to perfection, meet a layer of melted organic cheese. All nestled in a fresh bagel that’s crisp on the outside, cloud-soft inside. It’s comfort stripped to its essentials—no noise, no fuss, just pure, golden satisfaction. The kind of breakfast that reminds you: less really can be everything
$8.00

Beef Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel
Morning’s greatest hits, remastered. Smoky, crackling beef layered with rich, golden organic eggs and a melt of organic cheese that oozes into every warm crevice of a freshly baked bagel. It’s comfort with a conscience—crafted from the good stuff, no shortcuts, no compromises. The kind of breakfast that doesn’t shout “wake up” … it sings it
$10.00
Sausage, Egg & Cheese
Golden mornings, grounded in goodness. Juicy, perfectly seasoned chicken sausage meets fluffy organic eggs and smooth, melted organic cheese—all tucked into a freshly toasted bagel that holds it together like a soft sunrise hug. It’s the breakfast that plays both sides: hearty but clean, classic but conscious. Comfort food that doesn’t slow you down—it sets you up to win the day
$10.00

Vegan Sausage Breakfast Bagel
A fluffy vegan egg that tastes like the real thing, layered with your choice of hearty vegan sausage - packing all the flavor, none of the guilt. Melted vegan cheese ties it together in creamy harmony, hugged by a warm, toasted bagel that holds it all just right. It’s comfort reimagined for the modern morning—wholesome, satisfying, and 100% deliciously alive
$14.50
Vegan Bacon Breakfast Bagel
A fluffy vegan egg that tastes like the real thing, layered with your choice of sizzling vegan bacon - packing all the flavor, none of the guilt. Melted vegan cheese ties it together in creamy harmony, hugged by a warm, toasted bagel that holds it all just right. It’s comfort reimagined for the modern morning—wholesome, satisfying, and 100% deliciously alive
$16.50

Turkey Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel
Morning’s greatest hits, remastered. Smoky, crackling turkey bacon layered with rich, golden organic eggs and a melt of organic cheese that oozes into every warm crevice of a freshly baked bagel. It’s comfort with a conscience—crafted from the good stuff, no shortcuts, no compromises. The kind of breakfast that doesn’t shout “wake up” … it sings it
$10.00

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich Box
Turkey or beef bacon, organic eggs, and american cheese on your choice of freshly baked bagels
$144.00

Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich Box
Organic eggs and american cheese on your choice of freshly baked bagels
$115.00

Chicken Sausage, Egg & Cheese Bagel Sandwich Box
Organic eggs, chicken sausage, and american cheese on your choice of freshly baked bagels
$144.00

Cinnamon Raisin Classic Box
Smooth cream cheese and sweet fruit jam on warm cinnamon raisin bagels. Comforting, nostalgic, and prepared just the way it's meant to be
$115.00
Vegan Breakfast Bagel Sandwich Box
Vegan sausage, vegan egg, and dairy-free cheese on your choice of bagels. 100% vegan and fully satisfying
$210.00
Yogurt Parfait Pack
Creamy greek yogurt layered with organic granola and fresh seasonal berries
$54.00
Overnight Oats Pack
Rolled oats soaked with oat milk, greek yogurt, maple syrup, cardamom, cinnamon, and chia seeds — topped with blueberries
$57.00
Assorted Fruit Bowl Pack
Six individual fruit bowls filled with a chef-selected mix of fresh, seasonal fruit. Light, refreshing, and the perfect balance to any spread
$50.00
Watermelon Bowl Pack
Six individual bowls of freshly cut, juicy watermelon. Clean, refreshing, and always a crowd favorite
$42.00
Cheeseboard Snack Cup Pack
A snackable duo of swiss & sharp cheddar, paired with a crunchy mix of hazelnuts, brazil nuts, pecans, almonds & cashews, and seedless grapes. Balanced, sweet, savory, and satisfying
$68.00
Organic Eggs & Pink Himalayan Salt Pack
A simple, protein-forward option done right. This pack includes six individual containers, each filled with two perfectly boiled eggs and paired with pink himalayan sea salt for clean, balanced flavor. Thoughtfully portioned, easy to share, and ideal as a wholesome side or light bite alongside any order
$43.00
Classic Lox Special Bagel
Plain cream cheese and silky smoked salmon layered on perfectly baked bagels. A new york staple that never misses
$16.00

Manhattan Lox Special Bagel
Smoked salmon with scallion cream cheese, juicy tomato, crisp onion, and briny capers. Bold, refined, and unmistakably new york
$18.00

Nova Salmon & Avocado Special Bagel
Silky nova smoked salmon layered with ripe avocado, crisp cucumber, fresh dill, and lemon. A lighter, wellness-forward crowd favorite
$18.00
Avocado Toast Bagel
Fresh smashed avocado with lemon, tomato, furikake (contains sesame seeds), and sea salt on toasted bagels. Vibrant, satisfying, and always popular
$13.00

Caprese Bagel
Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, and torn basil layered on a lightly toasted bagel, finished with extra virgin olive oil and balsamic glaze. Simple, vibrant, and perfectly balanced. A premium vegetarian classic. (Prepared as is.)
$14.50
Turkey & Swiss Bagel
Roasted turkey layered with creamy swiss, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, and mayo & dijon. Stacked generously and built to satisfy
$16.00

Classic Egg Salad Bagel
Creamy organic egg salad with crisp lettuce and fresh onion on fresh-baked bagels. Simple, comforting, and dependable
$9.50

Classic Chicken Salad Bagel
House-made chicken salad with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Familiar flavors, elevated with care
$13.50

Classic Tuna Salad Bagel
Wild-caught albacore tuna salad with lettuce and tomato. Clean, classic, and reliably crowd-pleasing
$14.50

Classic Smoked Whitefish Bagel
House-made smoked whitefish salad. Smoky, silky, and deeply traditional. Layered with crisp cucumber, fresh onion, and juicy tomato on fresh-baked bagels. A true new york favorite, done right
$17.00

Bagels & Cream Cheese Box
Fresh-baked bagels generously spread with a chef-selected cream cheese, chosen daily for balance and freshness. Simple, timeless, and perfect any time of day
$90.00
Classic Egg Salad Box
Creamy organic egg salad with crisp lettuce and fresh onion on fresh-baked bagels. Simple, comforting, and dependable
$114.00
Classic Lox Special Box
Plain cream cheese and silky smoked salmon layered on perfectly baked bagels. A new york staple that never misses
$204.00
Manhattan Lox Special Box
Smoked salmon with scallion cream cheese, juicy tomato, crisp onion, and briny capers. Bold, refined, and unmistakably new york
$259.00
Nova Salmon & Avocado Box
Silky nova smoked salmon layered with ripe avocado, crisp cucumber, fresh dill, and lemon. A lighter, wellness-forward crowd favorite
$228.00
Avocado Toast Bagel Box
Fresh smashed avocado with lemon, tomato, furikake (contains sesame seeds), and sea salt on toasted bagels. Vibrant, satisfying, and always popular
$187.00
Turkey & Swiss Box
Roasted turkey layered with creamy swiss, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, and mayo & dijon. Stacked generously and built to satisfy
$192.00
Classic Smoked Whitefish Box
House-made smoked whitefish salad. Smoky, silky, and deeply traditional. Layered with crisp cucumber, fresh onion, and juicy tomato on fresh-baked bagels. A true new york favorite, done right
$204.00
Classic Tuna Salad Box
Wild-caught albacore tuna salad with lettuce and tomato. Clean, classic, and reliably crowd-pleasing
$174.00
Classic Chicken Salad Box
House-made chicken salad with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Familiar flavors, elevated with care
$162.00
Assorted Deli Classics Box
A chef-curated selection of our most iconic deli-style bagel sandwiches. Balanced, familiar, and built to please a crowd
$168.00
Small Seasonal Fruit Platter
Hand-picked seasonal fruits, beautifully arranged and perfect for sharing
$84.00

Artisan Cookie & Muffin Tray
A simple, crowd-pleasing assortment featuring 6 fresh-baked chocolate chip cookies and 6 muffins of your choice. Soft, chewy cookies paired with tender, house-made muffins create an easy, elevated option for meetings, brunches, or any gathering that needs a clean, reliable sweet spread. Muffins do not contain nuts
$95.00
Small Cheese & Fruit Platter
A fresh, colorful medley of seasonal fruits, paired with aged cheddar and swiss cheeses
$108.00

Veggie Garnish Tray
Tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, and capers – the perfect complement to any bagel board
$50.00

Small Schmear & Bagel Tray
A selection of three artisanal schmears and fresh cut veggies. Served with freshly baked bagels
$120.00

Small Classic Lox & Schmear Platter
Premium nova smoked salmon with tomatoes, red onions, capers, and three schmears. Served with fresh bagels and lemon-dill garnish
$240.00

Small Tray of NYC Smoked Fish & Schmear Spread
A classic nyc spread featuring nova lox, whitefish salad, plain and scallion schmears, fresh bagels, and all the garnishes – tomato, cucumber, red onion, capers, and lemon
$252.00

Assorted Muffins
A chef-selected assortment of our freshly baked muffins. Including blueberry, corn, cranberry orange, double chocolate, and chocolate chip. Soft, comforting, and just the right amount of sweet. Muffins do not contain nuts
$43.00
Side of Hash Browns
Two crispy, golden hash brown rounds. Hot, crunchy, and irresistibly snackable. Simple comfort, done right
$6.00

Hash Brown Side Pack
Twelve crispy, golden hash brown rounds. Two per serving. Freshly cooked and packed hot for sharing
$43.00
Box of Hot Coffee
Locally roasted, freshly brewed organic Counter Culture Coffee. Includes cups, lids, stirrers, and fixings
$45.00

Fresh Orange Juice Pack
Freshly squeezed, cold-pressed juices. No concentrates or additives
$65.00
Saratoga Still Water Pack
Pure, still saratoga spring water
$30.00
Box of Iced Coffee
Locally roasted, freshly brewed organic Counter Culture Coffee. Includes cups, lids, stirrers, and fixings. Ice is not included
$45.00
Martinelli Apple Juice Pack
$36.00
Sparkling Water Pack
Crisp saratoga sparkling spring water
$30.00
We are constantly adding new restaurants on CaterCow, so some menus haven't been reviewed yet!
Order now and leave a review and you will receive 2,000 CaterCoins, redeemable for Amazon Gift Cards or a discount off future orders!
Select a menu and then send a link to your team, letting everyone pick their perfect meal. No need to send a million emails or keep track in a clunky spreadsheet. Plus, there is no confusion when the order arrives - each meal is labeled with each individual's name!
Learn MoreSure, CaterCow makes it easy to plan your meals and order yourself but that can be draining! Go on autopilot and one of our account managers can craft the perfect meal plan to meet your team's recurring catering needs while you focus on your regular day-to-day. No contracts! No hassle!
Learn MoreShare your CaterCow experiences through reviews and earn CaterCoins. Use them to treat your team to a discounted future order or to snag an Amazon gift card. (Because you deserve it!)
Learn More| Delivery Area | Delivery Fee | Minimum |
|---|---|---|
| 10 miles from Lexington Ave. Store | $35 | $100 |
| Monday - Sunday | 6:00am | - | 3:00pm |
|---|