Signature Sandwiches and Salads
Choose from our healthy-ish sandwiches and salads that are never short on flavor.
$15.00 Per Person
Sandwell
412 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA
94% Recent Order Success Rate
Sandwell Catering Reviews
Des B.
60 Person Order
Sep, 2025
5 stars
Ewa K.
29 Person Order
Sep, 2025
Sandwiches were a little too bready, but overall tasty.
Jonathan A.
27 Person Order
Aug, 2025
4 stars
Jennifer
7 Person Order
Aug, 2025
5 stars
Lily R.
8 Person Order
Jul, 2025
5 stars
Sammie S.
11 Person Order
Jul, 2025
5 stars
Matthew R.
54 Person Order
Jul, 2025
5 stars
Jonathan A.
80 Person Order
Jul, 2025
4 stars
Verified Customer
23 Person Order
Jul, 2025
4 stars
Madeline G.
15 Person Order
Jul, 2025
The sandwiches are large! Some people may share halves. I got 15 sandwiches and there was 3 left. I got 5 salads too. The food temperature was still hot. The variety of flavors is amazing. It seems like there is only poultry or veggie-based sandwiches which I didn't realize until a coworker asked why I ordered so many chicken sandwiches. The salads were a good size, one person could have the whole bowl or you could share with someone. The dressing seems like a good portion. I would order again for sure!
Yardley G.
26 Person Order
Jul, 2025
Bread was hard. Wasn't pleased with the food.
Mollie S.
280 Person Order
Jul, 2025
5 stars
Jonathan A.
43 Person Order
Jun, 2025
4 stars
Edwin R.
33 Person Order
Jun, 2025
5 stars
Matthew R.
8 Person Order
Jun, 2025
5 stars
Heather F.
100 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Jennifer
17 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Emmanuelle P.
30 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Katie P.
30 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Matthew R.
20 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Karen M.
30 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Karen M.
50 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Louise S.
19 Person Order
May, 2025
We ordered this for staff dinner at a work event and everybody loved it!!
Verified Customer
27 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Taylor G.
27 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Jonathan A.
99 Person Order
May, 2025
4 stars
Lauren F.
80 Person Order
May, 2025
A 10/10 experience, will definitely order again! The food arrived on time, everything was beautifully labeled, smelled delicious, and tasted delicious too. Our group was raving about the green goddess salad dressing. Everyone loved the choices of sandwiches. Serving halves and salad is great for a group lunch. I was able to call in the hours leading up to delivery to confirm that everything was set to arrive on time. It was reassuring to be able to get in touch with a human. It was raining the morning of delivery and everything arrived completely dry. Thank you!!!
Roxanna R.
10 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Downtown Elementary School
35 Person Order
May, 2025
5 stars
Matthew R.
22 Person Order
Apr, 2025
5 stars
Karen M.
20 Person Order
Apr, 2025
5 stars
Heather F.
90 Person Order
Apr, 2025
5 stars
Gabrielle D.
30 Person Order
Apr, 2025
5 stars
Alphonso B.
10 Person Order
Apr, 2025
5 stars
Mervin M.
100 Person Order
Apr, 2025
5 stars
Jonathan A.
88 Person Order
Apr, 2025
4 stars
John M.
17 Person Order
Apr, 2025
5 stars
Mollie S.
265 Person Order
Apr, 2025
5 stars
Danni W.
35 Person Order
Apr, 2025
4 stars
Alphonso B.
10 Person Order
Apr, 2025
Quick efficient delivery, well packaged, and most important very tasty. Thanks
Joanna B.
35 Person Order
Apr, 2025
5 stars
Matthew R.
5 Person Order
Mar, 2025
5 stars
People O.
14 Person Order
Mar, 2025
5 stars
Matthew R.
18 Person Order
Mar, 2025
5 stars
Nina T.
25 Person Order
Mar, 2025
5 stars
Roxanna R.
10 Person Order
Feb, 2025
5 stars
Taylor G.
13 Person Order
Feb, 2025
5 stars
Jericha R.
55 Person Order
Feb, 2025
5 stars
Jericha R.
15 Person Order
Feb, 2025
5 stars
Jenny B
32 Person Order
Feb, 2025
5 stars
Mervin M.
100 Person Order
Feb, 2025
5 stars
Lindsay C.
101 Person Order
Feb, 2025
5 stars
Accrete Meal Planner
11 Person Order
Feb, 2025
5 stars
Mollie S.
250 Person Order
Feb, 2025
5 stars
Jonathan A.
134 Person Order
Feb, 2025
4 stars
Mervin M.
100 Person Order
Jan, 2025
5 stars
Pamela R.
30 Person Order
Jan, 2025
Have used them before and will use them again. Very reliable and good bang for your buck.
Michelle R.
26 Person Order
Jan, 2025
5 stars
Michael P.
19 Person Order
Jan, 2025
5 stars
Ty M.
45 Person Order
Jan, 2025
4 stars
Angela R.
185 Person Order
Jan, 2025
5 stars
Lily R.
9 Person Order
Dec, 2024
5 stars
Taylor G.
9 Person Order
Dec, 2024
5 stars
Jonathan A.
109 Person Order
Dec, 2024
4 stars
People O.
16 Person Order
Dec, 2024
5 stars
Katie P.
35 Person Order
Dec, 2024
5 stars
Emily D.
20 Person Order
Dec, 2024
5 stars
Mollie S.
200 Person Order
Dec, 2024
5 stars
Arlene D.
10 Person Order
Nov, 2024
4 stars
Mervin M.
100 Person Order
Nov, 2024
5 stars
Jonathan A.
106 Person Order
Nov, 2024
4 stars
Sarah M.
20 Person Order
Oct, 2024
5 stars
Lauren Y.
11 Person Order
Oct, 2024
4 stars
Mollie S.
200 Person Order
Oct, 2024
5 stars
Tynisha H.
40 Person Order
Oct, 2024
5 stars
Luis M.
38 Person Order
Oct, 2024
5 stars
Jonathan A.
48 Person Order
Oct, 2024
5 stars
Christine C.
10 Person Order
Oct, 2024
5 stars
Hussein N.
35 Person Order
Oct, 2024
5 stars
Srikavya J.
15 Person Order
Oct, 2024
4 stars
Luis M.
32 Person Order
Sep, 2024
5 stars
Marketing Division
44 Person Order
Sep, 2024
5 stars
Hussein N.
115 Person Order
Sep, 2024
5 stars
Tynisha H.
75 Person Order
Sep, 2024
Amazing spread and flawless delivery! So yummy! The Pesto and Chicken Parm sandwiches were a big hit! Bread is always fresh and sandwiches are delivered hot! Outstanding!
Mollie S.
227 Person Order
Sep, 2024
Our team loved these!
Taylor G.
7 Person Order
Aug, 2024
5 stars
peter W.
27 Person Order
Aug, 2024
We have ordered before and the team enjoyed the previous meal, this time was underwhelming. good portions. just not special.
Luis M.
39 Person Order
Aug, 2024
5 stars
Jonathan A.
60 Person Order
Aug, 2024
4 stars
Nikki L.
40 Person Order
Jul, 2024
5 stars
Hussein N.
32 Person Order
Jul, 2024
5 stars
Lindsey R.
33 Person Order
Jul, 2024
5 stars
Cynthia M.
18 Person Order
Jul, 2024
5 stars
Hussein N.
40 Person Order
Jul, 2024
5 stars
Luis M.
38 Person Order
Jul, 2024
4 stars
peter W.
24 Person Order
Jul, 2024
It's basic and can be pleasing but its not always consistent.
Jonathan A.
99 Person Order
Jul, 2024
5 stars
Kristen M.
27 Person Order
Jul, 2024
4 stars
Stephanie J.
42 Person Order
Jun, 2024
4 stars
Kanako M.
21 Person Order
Jun, 2024
4 stars
Hussein N.
35 Person Order
Jun, 2024
5 stars
Luis M.
40 Person Order
Jun, 2024
5 stars
Lucian C.
33 Person Order
Jun, 2024
5 stars
Cassie
56 Person Order
Jun, 2024
5 stars
Tawanna T.
12 Person Order
Jun, 2024
4 stars
Ty M.
34 Person Order
Jun, 2024
5 stars
Hussein N.
25 Person Order
Jun, 2024
5 stars
Jacalyn
35 Person Order
Jun, 2024
Great!
Hannah S.
17 Person Order
Jun, 2024
5 stars
Jonathan A.
29 Person Order
Jun, 2024
5 stars
Mollie S.
220 Person Order
Jun, 2024
5 stars
Eddie L.
45 Person Order
May, 2024
This was the highlight of the night. It's usually very difficult to please everyone with food but they kncoked it out of the park. The presentation and professionalism was also on point
Jonathan A.
45 Person Order
May, 2024
5 stars
Kristen M.
22 Person Order
May, 2024
5 stars
Lindsey R.
43 Person Order
May, 2024
5 stars
Victoria
68 Person Order
May, 2024
5 stars
Jonathan A.
10 Person Order
May, 2024
5 stars
Philip M.
15 Person Order
May, 2024
5 stars
Hannah S.
16 Person Order
Apr, 2024
5 stars
Hannah S.
107 Person Order
Apr, 2024
5 stars
Megin T.
19 Person Order
Apr, 2024
5 stars
April
18 Person Order
Apr, 2024
5 stars
CaterCow Meal Planner
10 Person Order
Apr, 2024
5 stars
Jonathan A.
53 Person Order
Apr, 2024
5 stars
Pamela R.
30 Person Order
Mar, 2024
This was one of our favorite sandwich places so far. Cater Cow makes it so easy to order great food at great prices. :)
Jacalyn
36 Person Order
Mar, 2024
5 stars
Amanda H.
50 Person Order
Mar, 2024
Arrived early! All the sandwiches were clearly labeled and a big hit with everyone. Love that we could adhere to everyone's dietary restrictions!
Amelia L.
19 Person Order
Mar, 2024
5 stars
Jonathan A.
49 Person Order
Mar, 2024
5 stars
Mollie S.
250 Person Order
Mar, 2024
5 stars
Get To Know CaterCow
Empower Your Team with Group Ordering
Select a menu and then send a link to your team, letting everyone pick their perfect meal. No need to send a million emails or keep track in a clunky spreadsheet. Plus, there is no confusion when the order arrives - each meal is labeled with each individual's name!
Learn MoreLet Us Concierge Your Meal Program
Sure, CaterCow makes it easy to plan your meals and order yourself but that can be draining! Go on autopilot and one of our account managers can craft the perfect meal plan to meet your team's recurring catering needs while you focus on your regular day-to-day. No contracts! No hassle!
Learn MoreEarn Rewards on Every Order
Share your CaterCow experiences through reviews and earn CaterCoins. Use them to treat your team to a discounted future order or to snag an Amazon gift card. (Because you deserve it!)
Learn MoreSandwell Catering Delivery Information
Manhattan
| Delivery Area | Delivery Fee | Minimum |
|---|---|---|
| Upper East Side | 10% | $100 |
| Midtown West | 10% | $100 |
| Upper West Side | 10% | $100 |
| Harlem | 10% | $100 |
| Washington Heights & The Bronx | 10% + $25 | $150 |
Queens
| Delivery Area | Delivery Fee | Minimum |
|---|---|---|
| Astoria & Roosevelt Island | 10% + $25 | $150 |
| Long Island City and Greenpoint | 10% + $25 | $150 |
New Jersey
| Delivery Area | Delivery Fee | Minimum |
|---|---|---|
| Jersey City & Hoboken | 12% + $20 | $250 |
| Bayonne | 12% + $20 | $250 |
| Newark | 12% + $50 | $250 |
| Linden to New Brunswick | 12% + $85 | $250 |
| North Jersey Suburbs | 12% + $85 | $250 |
Staten Island
| Delivery Area | Delivery Fee | Minimum |
|---|---|---|
| Staten Island | 12% + $20 | $250 |
Westchester County
| Delivery Area | Delivery Fee | Minimum |
|---|---|---|
| Yonkers, Eastchester, and Larchmont | 12% + $20 | $250 |
| Rye, White Plains, and Tarrytown | 12% + $50 | $250 |
| Metro North Connecticut | 12% + $85 | $250 |
Long Island
| Delivery Area | Delivery Fee | Minimum |
|---|---|---|
| Long Island | 12% + $50 | $250 |
Sandwell Catering Hours
| Monday - Sunday | 10:00am | - | 9:00pm |
|---|