"
Tompkins Square Bagels & Bakery logo - one of the top restaurants for catering in New York City

Tompkins Square Bagels & Bakery

184 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003, USA

4.86 (288 reviews)

98% Recent Order Success Rate

Tompkins Square Bagels & Bakery Catering Reviews

Yael R.

18 Person Order

Apr, 2025

5 stars

Sarah M.

17 Person Order

Apr, 2025

5 stars

Hayley P.

10 Person Order

Mar, 2025

Great sandwiches!

Maximus D.

20 Person Order

Mar, 2025

5 stars

Jonathan A.

50 Person Order

Feb, 2025

4 stars

Pema D.

24 Person Order

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Sami H.

20 Person Order

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Nicole L.

15 Person Order

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Christine C.

11 Person Order

Feb, 2025

4 stars

Sami H.

22 Person Order

Jan, 2025

5 stars

Laura C.

20 Person Order

Jan, 2025

5 stars

Jonathan A.

50 Person Order

Dec, 2024

4 stars

Sami H.

20 Person Order

Dec, 2024

5 stars

Devon H.

15 Person Order

Nov, 2024

5 stars

Gonzalo C.

30 Person Order

Nov, 2024

5 stars

Jonathan A.

50 Person Order

Nov, 2024

4 stars

Sami H.

22 Person Order

Nov, 2024

Great bagels and great presentation. Could use more cream cheese for the ratio to bagels but otherwise perfect.

Sami H.

20 Person Order

Nov, 2024

5 stars

Sonny A.

51 Person Order

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Jamie C.

30 Person Order

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Jamie C.

30 Person Order

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Cora P.

14 Person Order

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Sami H.

27 Person Order

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Stephanie M.

20 Person Order

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Jonathan A.

50 Person Order

Oct, 2024

5 stars

Lauren S.

13 Person Order

Sep, 2024

5 stars

Sami H.

20 Person Order

Sep, 2024

5 stars

Justin G.

17 Person Order

Sep, 2024

5 stars

Karen P.

25 Person Order

Sep, 2024

5 stars

Rosemarie R.

45 Person Order

Sep, 2024

5 stars

Sonny A.

51 Person Order

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Downtown Middle School

50 Person Order

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Jen C.

15 Person Order

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Vincent T.

30 Person Order

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Rosemarie R.

45 Person Order

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Sami H.

20 Person Order

Aug, 2024

The bagels were great, and they give a solid amount of toppings, especially the lox. Only thing is there is not a proportionate amount of cream cheese so you may need to order extra.

Sonny A.

51 Person Order

Jul, 2024

5 stars

Rosemarie R.

45 Person Order

Jul, 2024

5 stars

Stephanie J.

15 Person Order

Jun, 2024

4 stars

Sonny A.

51 Person Order

Jun, 2024

On time, labeled properly and food was great.

Anila A.

13 Person Order

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Rosemarie R.

45 Person Order

Jun, 2024

I get these for our office every single month!! Our team looks forward to having them every month and they are always dying to know where they are from. AMAZING!! They are so so good!

Paul

92 Person Order

May, 2024

5 stars

Rosemarie R.

45 Person Order

May, 2024

5 stars

Sonny A.

36 Person Order

May, 2024

Sandwiches were great and it was a bit hit overall.

Vonnie R.

130 Person Order

May, 2024

5 stars

Paul

144 Person Order

May, 2024

5 stars

Mary P.

40 Person Order

May, 2024

Really good!

Sonny A.

12 Person Order

May, 2024

Great selection of breakfast sandwiches that are all very good.

Willene H.

60 Person Order

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Wesley C.

17 Person Order

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Willene H.

60 Person Order

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Courtney R.

17 Person Order

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Vonnie R.

130 Person Order

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Paul

25 Person Order

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Mina L.

30 Person Order

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Willene H.

70 Person Order

Apr, 2024

Great bagels, fast delivery! Will order again!

Rosemarie R.

55 Person Order

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Sharif B.

35 Person Order

Mar, 2024

5 stars

Amanda H.

50 Person Order

Mar, 2024

Great bagels! Super surprised they're vegan and the gluten-free bagels are awesome and look so similar to the regular bagels we were glad they were already separated for us so we could tell them apart. And the cream cheese choices are excellent.

Vonnie R.

25 Person Order

Mar, 2024

5 stars

Rosemarie R.

60 Person Order

Feb, 2024

They taste INCREDIBLE!! The whole office loved them! We will be ordering from here again! Beautiful presentation.

Sharif B.

110 Person Order

Feb, 2024

5 stars

Mollie S.

150 Person Order

Feb, 2024

5 stars

Nicole L.

25 Person Order

Jan, 2024

5 stars

Mollie S.

150 Person Order

Dec, 2023

5 stars

Tiarra B.

40 Person Order

Nov, 2023

5 stars

Carena P.

33 Person Order

Nov, 2023

5 stars

Mollie S.

150 Person Order

Nov, 2023

5 stars

Katy E.

20 Person Order

Nov, 2023

5 stars

Devon K.

45 Person Order

Nov, 2023

5 stars

Kaela P.

24 Person Order

Nov, 2023

5 stars

Katie G.

27 Person Order

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Katie G.

21 Person Order

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Miguel V.

11 Person Order

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Ilana S.

40 Person Order

Oct, 2023

4 stars

Christine C.

30 Person Order

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Sarah M.

25 Person Order

Sep, 2023

4 stars

Mollie S.

185 Person Order

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Sharif B.

15 Person Order

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Sharif B.

15 Person Order

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Ida S.

40 Person Order

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Verified Customer

25 Person Order

Aug, 2023

I scheduled the food to be delivered for 9am and the delivery driver arrived at 8:20am when no one was in the office. I scheduled the meal for 9 because that is my time of arrival. The driver informed me that he was told to arrive for 8:30 which was still too early for a 9am start. We were able to work it out, but it was annoying to have to deal with during my commute. Another big issue is that nowhere on the order page does it say that the bagels that were being provided were going to be from an assortment of bagels. It just said bagels and eggs, meat etc. on the site with no option to choose what kind of bagels you want. I only wanted plain bagels which is what I thought I was getting since again, nothing on the website indicated that it would be an assortment of bagel flavors being sent instead. None of the sandwiches were labeled with what kind of bagel it was which made the situation even worse. There was no way to know what sandwich went with what bagel without completely opening up the sandwiches because they chose to give an assortment but then provided no labels. Overall the bagel I had was tasty but this was rough for a first experience with the restaurant and with Catercow's breakfast ordering/delivery system.

Nick F.

55 Person Order

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Michelle F.

60 Person Order

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Dan S.

100 Person Order

Aug, 2023

Lots of compliments on the great bagels. And the Bacon and Herb cream cheese is a rare choice. It was a huge hit!

Tiarra B.

10 Person Order

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Michelle C.

35 Person Order

Jul, 2023

5 stars

Allison T.

10 Person Order

Jul, 2023

5 stars

Mollie S.

130 Person Order

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Tiarra B.

10 Person Order

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Katie G.

18 Person Order

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Eddie L.

50 Person Order

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Eddie L.

30 Person Order

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Eddie L.

20 Person Order

May, 2023

5 stars

Kelsey D.

25 Person Order

May, 2023

5 stars

Mollie S.

150 Person Order

May, 2023

5 stars

Jericha

22 Person Order

May, 2023

3 stars

Imogene L.

360 Person Order

May, 2023

5 stars

Tanya D.

90 Person Order

Apr, 2023

4 stars

Ana B.

23 Person Order

Apr, 2023

They delivered with impeccable timing. Received a txt they were on their way and a txt after completing delivery. Really beautiful and delicious lox and bagels. Thank you!

Mollie S.

115 Person Order

Apr, 2023

5 stars

Amanda B.

35 Person Order

Apr, 2023

4 stars

Mollie S.

150 Person Order

Apr, 2023

5 stars

Cora P.

10 Person Order

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Kaela P.

50 Person Order

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Kaela P.

30 Person Order

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Mollie S.

150 Person Order

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Kaela P.

25 Person Order

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Katie G.

12 Person Order

Feb, 2023

5 stars

Ramona W.

12 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Mollie S.

160 Person Order

Jan, 2023

Great!

Tori S.

27 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Katie G.

20 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Mollie S.

80 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Helen H.

14 Person Order

Jan, 2023

Delicious bagels!

Mollie S.

50 Person Order

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Ryan G.

30 Person Order

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Johan B.

46 Person Order

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Roxana M.

50 Person Order

Dec, 2022

Bagels were delicious and filling. Delivery on time

Courtney S.

30 Person Order

Dec, 2022

4 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Katie G.

15 Person Order

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Cora P.

10 Person Order

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Nick C.

50 Person Order

Oct, 2022

4 stars

Mollie S.

176 Person Order

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Camille A.

62 Person Order

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Gretchen (.

150 Person Order

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Katie G.

25 Person Order

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Tammi G.

30 Person Order

Sep, 2022

I ordered a continental breakfast for my meeting and the bagels and baked goods were excellent. I like that they give large amounts of cream cheese & butter in bowls - feels more authentic than the little containers of Philadelphia cream cheese : )

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Laurencia G.

105 Person Order

Sep, 2022

Bagels were warm and fresh. Everything was well put together and delicious. Our gluten free people were especially excited that they got to enjoy bagels too.

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Danielle H.

40 Person Order

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Amelia L.

11 Person Order

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Courtney S.

25 Person Order

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Gretchen (.

100 Person Order

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Windsor Terrace Middle School

70 Person Order

Aug, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

65 Person Order

Jul, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

50 Person Order

Jul, 2022

5 stars

Leadership P.

20 Person Order

Jul, 2022

5 stars

Jenna B.

8 Person Order

Jul, 2022

4 stars

Jenna B.

12 Person Order

Jul, 2022

4 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Jul, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

45 Person Order

Jul, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

50 Person Order

Jun, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Jun, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Jun, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Jun, 2022

5 stars

casey c.

20 Person Order

Jun, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

May, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

May, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

May, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

May, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

May, 2022

5 stars

LaShawn H.

32 Person Order

May, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

casey c.

25 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

casey c.

40 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Mar, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Mar, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Mar, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

70 Person Order

Mar, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Mar, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Feb, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

80 Person Order

Feb, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

80 Person Order

Feb, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

50 Person Order

Feb, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

80 Person Order

Jan, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

40 Person Order

Jan, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

80 Person Order

Dec, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

80 Person Order

Dec, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

95 Person Order

Nov, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

45 Person Order

Nov, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

80 Person Order

Nov, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

100 Person Order

Nov, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

80 Person Order

Oct, 2021

5 stars

Jamell W.

100 Person Order

Oct, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

60 Person Order

Oct, 2021

5 stars

Sara D.

70 Person Order

Aug, 2021

5 stars

Sara D.

70 Person Order

Aug, 2021

5 stars

Yiwen L.

28 Person Order

Aug, 2021

5 stars

Stacie J.

25 Person Order

Feb, 2020

The food wasn't nearly as fresh this time as the first time we ordered here so that was disappointing. And we had to send two people down and get the food from the delivery person because they said they couldn't find anywhere to park. So we had to set everything up ourselves. We'll order again though and give it another go since the two experiences we had were different.

Stacie J.

25 Person Order

Jan, 2020

Food was tasty and very fresh, and notes were followed requesting to have bacon left off the sandwiches so thank you. My only suggestion would be it would be great to receive condiments like mustard and mayo for the sandwiches. We just received two huge tubs of hot sauce.

Jennifer C.

28 Person Order

Jan, 2020

Too early. Came more than 30 minutes early. Would appreciate a 15 minute window instead. I asked for 8:15 am and they cam before 7:45 am.

Katie K.

40 Person Order

Dec, 2019

5 stars

CLEAR (.

35 Person Order

Nov, 2019

Everything was really great

Get To Know CaterCow

Empower Your Team with Group Ordering

Select a menu and then send a link to your team, letting everyone pick their perfect meal. No need to send a million emails or keep track in a clunky spreadsheet. Plus, there is no confusion when the order arrives - each meal is labeled with each individual's name!

Learn More
Let Us Concierge Your Meal Program

Sure, CaterCow makes it easy to plan your meals and order yourself but that can be draining! Go on autopilot and one of our account managers can craft the perfect meal plan to meet your team's recurring catering needs while you focus on your regular day-to-day. No contracts! No hassle!

Learn More
Earn Rewards on Every Order

Share your CaterCow experiences through reviews and earn CaterCoins. Use them to treat your team to a discounted future order or to snag an Amazon gift card. (Because you deserve it!)

Learn More

Tompkins Square Bagels & Bakery Catering Delivery Information

Brooklyn
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
DUMBO & Downtown Brooklyn$60$100
Williamsburg$60$100
Prospect Park East$60$100
Prospect Park West$60$100
Clinton Hill and Bed Stuy$60$100
Manhattan
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
East Village$45$100
West & Greenwich Village$45$100
SoHo And Tribeca$45$100
Lower East Side$45$100
FiDi$45$100
Midtown East$45$100
Midtown West$45$100
Upper East Side$45$100
Upper West Side$45$100
Queens
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
Long Island City and Greenpoint$60$100

Tompkins Square Bagels & Bakery Catering Hours

Monday7:00am-6:00pm
Tuesday7:00am-6:00pm
Wednesday7:00am-6:00pm
Thursday7:00am-6:00pm
Friday7:00am-6:00pm
Saturday7:00am-10:00am
Sunday7:00am-10:00am