"
The Sandwich Shop logo - one of the top restaurants for catering in New York City

The Sandwich Shop

658a Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA

4.89 (107 reviews)

100% Recent Order Success Rate

0 issues in the last 22 orders

The Sandwich Shop Catering Reviews

Rafael D.

25 Person Order

Mar, 2025

5 stars

Achievement First B.

100 Person Order

Mar, 2025

5 stars

Matthew R.

15 Person Order

Mar, 2025

5 stars

Sarah M.

20 Person Order

Mar, 2025

5 stars

Christina J.

18 Person Order

Mar, 2025

The most delicious sandwiches! My team raved about them.

Aedrey G.

10 Person Order

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Dana

13 Person Order

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Pema D.

20 Person Order

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Achievement First B.

83 Person Order

Feb, 2025

5 stars

Achievement First B.

80 Person Order

Jan, 2025

4 stars

Aedrey G.

10 Person Order

Dec, 2024

5 stars

Achievement First B.

20 Person Order

Nov, 2024

5 stars

Milan F.

50 Person Order

Nov, 2024

5 stars

Achievement First B.

84 Person Order

Nov, 2024

5 stars

Todtiyana B.

52 Person Order

Aug, 2024

Food was flavorful and yummy would def order form here again!

Christine C.

12 Person Order

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Achievement First B.

20 Person Order

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Luis M.

38 Person Order

Aug, 2024

5 stars

Achievement First B.

80 Person Order

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Christine C.

15 Person Order

Jun, 2024

5 stars

Thaysha M.

45 Person Order

Apr, 2024

5 stars

Marketing Division

57 Person Order

Mar, 2024

5 stars

Achievement First B.

80 Person Order

Jan, 2024

5 stars

Devon K.

15 Person Order

Oct, 2023

5 stars

Joshua J.

12 Person Order

Oct, 2023

This place was great! Did a 12 sandwich lunch order for my groomsmen (and venue staff) to get ready, and the food was amazing, plentiful, and matched the description. Would definitely recommend them!

Michelle R.

50 Person Order

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Sarah M.

20 Person Order

Sep, 2023

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

38 Person Order

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Jeannely L.

140 Person Order

Aug, 2023

5 stars

Amelia L.

10 Person Order

Jun, 2023

5 stars

Sarah M.

18 Person Order

Jun, 2023

5 stars

CAMBA (Toni)

25 Person Order

May, 2023

5 stars

Sarah M.

16 Person Order

May, 2023

5 stars

Amelia L.

18 Person Order

Apr, 2023

5 stars

Nick C.

46 Person Order

Apr, 2023

4 stars

Sarah M.

24 Person Order

Apr, 2023

5 stars

monica K.

40 Person Order

Mar, 2023

5 stars

Paperless P.

42 Person Order

Feb, 2023

5 stars

Michael B.

29 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Shandel B.

11 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Mollie S.

125 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Amelia L.

10 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Mollie S.

35 Person Order

Jan, 2023

5 stars

Gabrielle D.

27 Person Order

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Sarah M.

16 Person Order

Dec, 2022

5 stars

Joanna B.

90 Person Order

Nov, 2022

Delicious food, earlier than expected, well organized and friendly delivery staff.

Mollie S.

70 Person Order

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Devon K.

25 Person Order

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Sarah M.

15 Person Order

Nov, 2022

5 stars

Mollie S.

125 Person Order

Oct, 2022

5 stars

Explore S.

15 Person Order

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Valerie L.

15 Person Order

Sep, 2022

5 stars

Michelle R.

55 Person Order

Aug, 2022

5 stars

Ashley R.

40 Person Order

Aug, 2022

4 stars

SueAnn D.

60 Person Order

Aug, 2022

3 stars

Bedstuy C.

50 Person Order

Aug, 2022

5 stars

Verified Customer

30 Person Order

Aug, 2022

The food was great (rave reviews from the team) and the customer service was really good. We maintained excellent communication throughout the process from both CaterCow and The Sandwich Shop. Also, the food was packaged well. The only issue was that they were 10 minutes late but that was due to crazy traffic in the area, and the restaurant was sure to maintain communication throughout the delay. Would definitely order again!

Teresa S.

15 Person Order

Aug, 2022

5 stars

Todtiyana B.

20 Person Order

Jul, 2022

The food was amazing! Perfect ration of all items in the bowl will definitely be ordering again

Teresa S.

15 Person Order

Jul, 2022

The lunch was tasty and delicious and everyone enjoyed the food. The delivery was timely and we would definitely order from again.

Elise W.

21 Person Order

Jun, 2022

Normal portions. Very fresh, served hot and on time!

Teresa S.

40 Person Order

May, 2022

Always a great choice for lunch for the team.

Amelia L.

85 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

SueAnn D.

50 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Michelle R.

45 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Eunice C.

35 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

Teresa S.

17 Person Order

Apr, 2022

Everyone thought the sandwiches and salads were delicious. The order was packed well and was easy to put out for everyone to consume.

SueAnn D.

50 Person Order

Apr, 2022

5 stars

SueAnn D.

55 Person Order

Mar, 2022

5 stars

SueAnn D.

60 Person Order

Mar, 2022

5 stars

Leadership Prep Ocean Hill (Samantha McClarin)

36 Person Order

Feb, 2022

Love them!

SueAnn D.

50 Person Order

Feb, 2022

Missing the drinks from my order.

Alexandra W.

35 Person Order

Jan, 2022

5 stars

Desiree (.

25 Person Order

Dec, 2021

The sandwiches and salads were delicious and delivery was prompt.

Fenix S.

82 Person Order

Nov, 2021

5 stars

doriann w.

50 Person Order

Nov, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

15 Person Order

Aug, 2021

5 stars

SueAnn D.

50 Person Order

Aug, 2021

5 stars

SueAnn D.

50 Person Order

Aug, 2021

Absolutely Amazing!!!

Mollie S.

15 Person Order

Jul, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

90 Person Order

Jul, 2021

5 stars

doriann w.

112 Person Order

Jul, 2021

5 stars

Mollie S.

50 Person Order

Jul, 2021

5 stars

doriann w.

66 Person Order

Jun, 2021

hands down, the BEST caprese sandwich ever! all sandwiches and salads were delicious!

Racquel

45 Person Order

Jun, 2021

5 stars

Racquel

25 Person Order

Jun, 2021

5 stars

Sarah R.

35 Person Order

Mar, 2020

Food was delicious and packaged conveniently for an event staff on the run.

Devon K.

32 Person Order

Feb, 2020

5 stars

Devon K.

12 Person Order

Dec, 2019

5 stars

Alexandra W.

25 Person Order

Dec, 2019

5 stars

Taryn

62 Person Order

Dec, 2019

5 stars

Devon K.

12 Person Order

Nov, 2019

5 stars

Katie G.

37 Person Order

Oct, 2019

Order was 45 minutes early (over an hour before serving time), and food was already lukewarm upon arrival. Otherwise pretty tasty!

Jacqueline K.

22 Person Order

Oct, 2019

The food was really good and packaged nicely. Delivery was late so my lunch meeting started without lunch. Restaurant is far from midtown so while you don't want your order arriving too early, I would definitely build in more time on the front end as it arriving late is not ideal either.

Carla N.

18 Person Order

Sep, 2019

5 stars

Erin C.

30 Person Order

Jun, 2019

5 stars

Elouise M.

15 Person Order

May, 2019

5 stars

Devon K.

28 Person Order

Apr, 2019

5 stars

Deborah

42 Person Order

Jan, 2019

5 stars

Brownsville C.

45 Person Order

Oct, 2018

5 stars

Grace T.

25 Person Order

Oct, 2018

4 stars

Alan I.

25 Person Order

Aug, 2018

The rice bowls were a big hit. In fact, people took additional bowls.

Get To Know CaterCow

Empower Your Team with Group Ordering

Select a menu and then send a link to your team, letting everyone pick their perfect meal. No need to send a million emails or keep track in a clunky spreadsheet. Plus, there is no confusion when the order arrives - each meal is labeled with each individual's name!

Learn More
Let Us Concierge Your Meal Program

Sure, CaterCow makes it easy to plan your meals and order yourself but that can be draining! Go on autopilot and one of our account managers can craft the perfect meal plan to meet your team's recurring catering needs while you focus on your regular day-to-day. No contracts! No hassle!

Learn More
Earn Rewards on Every Order

Share your CaterCow experiences through reviews and earn CaterCoins. Use them to treat your team to a discounted future order or to snag an Amazon gift card. (Because you deserve it!)

Learn More

The Sandwich Shop Catering Delivery Information

Brooklyn
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
Williamsburg$35$100
DUMBO & Downtown Brooklyn$50$100
East Williamsburg and Bushwick$50$100
Prospect Park East$50$100
Prospect Park West$50$100
Clinton Hill and Bed Stuy$50$100
Outer Brooklyn East$75$100
Outer Brooklyn West$75$100
Manhattan
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
East Village$50$100
West & Greenwich Village$60$100
SoHo And Tribeca$60$100
Lower East Side$50$100
FiDi$55$100
Midtown East$55$100
Midtown West$65$100
Upper East Side$75$100
Upper West Side$75$100
Harlem$75$100
Washington Heights & The Bronx$75$100
Queens
Delivery AreaDelivery FeeMinimum
Long Island City and Greenpoint$50$100
Astoria & Roosevelt Island$55$100
Mid-Queens$50$100
Outer Queens$50$100

The Sandwich Shop Catering Hours

Monday11:15am-8:00pm
Tuesday11:15am-8:00pm
Wednesday11:15am-8:00pm
Thursday11:15am-8:00pm
Friday11:15am-8:00pm
Saturday11:00am-8:00pm
Sunday11:00am-8:00pm

The Sandwich Shop Catering Packages