American Picnic

37 reviews

Perfect Picnic
Perfect Picnic
New York

Perfect flavor combinations from our picnics made easy in a delicious baguettini sandwich.

Package Details

Whats Included?

Your choice of Baguettinis (2 per person)

Reusable Branded Tote

North Fork potato chips

Chocolate chip cookie




Lunch / Dinner > Sandwiches & Wraps

Set up style

Basic Setup - Delivery person will unwrap food and arrange everything so it’s ready to be enjoyed

Presentation style

Individually Wrapped - Each portion will be boxed, bagged or wrapped and ready to take away


$14 per person plus delivery & service, $112 minimum order, 18 hours order notice required

Default choices

The CaterCow experts have pre-selected these choices that we consider to be crowd favorites!

Your choice of Baguettinis (2 per person)

  • Smoked Duck With Spiced Sour Cherry And Arugula
  • Prosciutto With Pear Ginger Jam And Blue Cheese
  • Turkey Breast With Aged Cheddar And Dijon Mayonnaise
  • Fresh Mozzarella With Tomato And Basil V

All choices

If you'd like to customize your order, choose from the following options on the checkout page:

Your choice of Baguettinis (2 per person)

  • Salami With Aged Cheddar And Arugula
  • Serrano Ham With Chives
  • Hot Soppressata With Spiced Dilly Green Bean
  • Smoked Duck With Spiced Sour Cherry And Arugula
  • Bresaola With Shaved Parmesan And Arugula
  • Pate With Cornichon And Dijon Mustard
  • Prosciutto With Pear Ginger Jam And Blue Cheese
  • Turkey Breast With Aged Cheddar And Dijon Mayonnaise
  • Fresh Mozzarella With Tomato And Basil V
  • Fresh Goat Cheese With Fig Jam V
  • Apple Saffron Chutney With Aged Cheddar V
  • Vegan saffron chutney with tomato and basil Vegan

Available Add Ons

  • Family Kale Salad w/ parmesan, cranberries and lemon (for 10 - 12)
  • Spring water
  • Sea salt brownie
  • Family arugula salad w/ goat cheese, pecans, and strawberries (for 10 - 12)
  • Fresh chocolate chip cookie
  • Family size Fresh Seasonal Fruit (for 8 - 10)
  • Sparkling water
  • Veggie crudite platter (for 8 - 10)
  • Individual Seasonal Side Salad (Per Person)
  • Family Greek Salad (for 10 - 12)
  • Local Cheese Platter with fruits, nuts, & crostini (for 8 - 10)
  • Charcuterie cured meats platter (for 8 - 10)
  • Local Cheese Platter with fruits, nuts, & crostini (for 12-15)
  • Mediterranean platter with Grape leaves, Feta, Olives, Tomato, Peperoncini (for 8 - 10)
  • Individual Cheese and Fruit Side (per person)


American Picnic
Overall Customer Satisfaction

37 reviews

5 Star (31)
4 Star (3)
3 Star (1)
2 Star (0)
1 Star (2)

Hannah Zander

I brought in the individual picnic lunches for staff doing an all-day training. They loved them! Not only was the packaging and delivery convenient and self-contained, but the sandwiches were delicious! I will definitely look for opportunities to use Perfect Picnic again.

Jul, 2013

Scarlett Allen

Perfect Picnic is wonderful and is a great treat for your office or team! I ordered perfect picnic for a team lunch last week and everyone LOVED it!!! The food was yummy and the presentation was delightful!! I highly recommend working with Wendy because she is truly exceptional and offers a great product!

Aug, 2013

Carrie Nichols

Working with Wendy on my first order on CaterCow was a pleasure. She was responsive to all my questions on quantity, delivery, etc. The presentation of the American Picnic was OUTSTANDING! All sandwiches were labeled inside and out (SUPER HELPFUL), the bags were very cute and such a hit at my meeting. The way the food was wrapped up in the white/red towel was just adorable. I love the attention to detail! Food quality was amazing. The duck baguettini was my fave! People are still talking about it this morning!

Aug, 2013

Kate Lehrhaupt

5 stars

Oct, 2013

Jenny Lozano

Good food and presentation

Dec, 2013

Ben Stern

The sandwiches are small, but they're delicious. We ordered some extra for the bigger eaters, and everyone was happy. People loved them!

Feb, 2014


Wendy was extremely flexible and professional when working with my complicated order. She ensured that each and every one of my coworkers received a personalized order. Her attention to detail is exceptional. The baguettinis were superb, favorites included the duck, prosciutto, and pate.

Apr, 2014

Scarlett Allen

Perfect Picnic is always amazing and so so so Yummy!

Aug, 2014


Excellent service. Excellent food. "Perfect" is in their name for a reason!

Dec, 2014

leah lemmens

Presentation was so Cute! Food was great and everyone loved it! we will use them again

Mar, 2015

allison comito

5 stars

Jun, 2017

Kay Lyn Byrne

Everyone loved these sandwiches and thought the presentation was great. We will definitely be ordering from here again!

Jan, 2017

Operations Personnel

5 stars

Jun, 2019

Alexsis Bass

5 stars

Mar, 2017

Kimberly Parker

5 stars

Aug, 2016

Lauren Gottlieb

Absolutely fantastic! Thank you!!!

Mar, 2017

Mark Cicco

1 stars

Jun, 2017

Michelle R Avant

5 stars

May, 2019

stacey haid

5 stars

Dec, 2018

CaterCow Cares

5 stars

Apr, 2020


It was great! Exactly as described on the website. Was very satisfied with everything provided.

Jun, 2020

Caterer Info

On-Time Delivery 92%
Response Rate 100%
Response Time 30 minutes

Delivery Areas

Area Delivery Fee
DUMBO & Downtown Brooklyn $35
Williamsburg $35
East Williamsburg and Bushwick $35
Outer Brooklyn West $45
Upper East Side $30
East Village $30
West & Greenwich Village $30
SoHo And Tribeca $30
Lower East Side $30
FiDi $30
Astoria $35
Long Island City and Greenpoint $45
Mid-Queens $35
Outer Queens $35
Outer Brooklyn East $45
Midtown East $30
Midtown West $30
Prospect Park East $45
Prospect Park West $45
Clinton Hill and Bed Stuy $45
Upper West Side $30
Harlem $30
Washington Heights and Inwood $30

Business Hours

Sunday 7:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Monday 7:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday 7:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday 7:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday 7:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday 7:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday 7:00 AM - 6:00 PM


Please enter your delivery details to order this package.


TOTAL price - delivery, tax, and fee included. You will not be charged yet.

Have A Question?

or call us at 1 (855) 269 4056

Also by this Caterer

Loading more packages...